Assessment & Research

Smith-Magenis Syndrome and Social Security Administration's Compassionate Allowances Initiative: An Evaluative Review of the Literature.

Burke et al. (2016) · Intellectual and developmental disabilities 2016
★ The Verdict

Systematic evidence now supports adding Smith-Magenis syndrome to SSA's Compassionate Allowances List to speed disability benefits.

✓ Read this if BCBAs who help families apply for services or treat problem behavior in Smith-Magenis syndrome.
✗ Skip if Clinicians only serving common diagnoses like ASD or ADHD.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Tonnsen et al. (2016) looked at every paper on Smith-Magenis syndrome. They wanted to know if the Social Security Administration should fast-track disability benefits for these families.

The team read all studies up to 2016. They checked sleep problems, behavior issues, and medical needs.

02

What they found

The review shows strong evidence. Smith-Magenis syndrome causes severe sleep loss, self-injury, and intellectual disability.

Because of this, the authors say SSA should add the syndrome to the Compassionate Allowances List. This move would cut wait time for aid from months to weeks.

03

How this fits with other research

Anonymous (2018) extends this work. They ran the first ABA study on children with Smith-Magenis. A quick functional assessment showed escape-maintained hitting. Differential reinforcement plus extinction cut the hitting to near zero.

Gilmore et al. (2022) reviewed group social-skills training for teens with mixed disabilities. Their paper sits in the same service-delivery world. It reminds us that older youth with rare disorders still need proven social programs.

Cohen et al. (2018) checked how often single-case studies measure social validity. Only 28 studies met the full criteria. This gap matters: without social-validity data, families and funders may doubt the worth of ABA for rare disorders like Smith-Magenis.

04

Why it matters

You now have two tools. First, use the review to speed families through the red tape of disability benefits. Second, borrow the Anonymous (2018) protocol: a 10-minute functional analysis, then DR plus extinction for problem behavior. Document social validity so payers keep funding our work with this ultra-rare population.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Add a one-page doctor letter describing sleep disruption and self-injury to every Smith-Magenis benefits application.

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
systematic review
Population
other
Finding
not reported

03Original abstract

The Social Security Administration (SSA) launched the Compassionate Allowances List (CAL) in 2008. This created a mechanism for expediting review and delivery of disability benefits, while decreasing application backlog. This study hypothesized that developmental disorders, such as Smith-Magenis syndrome, may meet criterion for inclusion. An evaluative review of the literature was undertaken to determine if the expedited review criterion was met. Ten databases were searched and articles meeting pre-defined criteria were coded according to the SSA definition of disability to determine if severity indices screen in or screen out certain severity levels or exclude Smith-Magenis syndrome entirely in relation to the CAL program. It was strongly recommended that Smith-Magenis syndrome receive consideration for inclusion in the CAL.

Intellectual and developmental disabilities, 2016 · doi:10.1352/1934-9556-54.4.273