Old World--new territory: European perspectives on intellectual disability.
European inclusion policy looked good on paper in 1997, but later studies prove only choice-filled community life produces real gains.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Walsh (1997) scanned Europe to see how well countries were including people with intellectual disability.
The paper lists laws, funding moves, and cross-border projects started in the 1990s.
It is a story-style review, not a lab study, so no single group was tested.
What they found
Most nations had closed large institutions and written inclusion policies.
Yet housing, work, and health gaps stayed wide, so the author called for shared European action.
How this fits with other research
Vassos et al. (2016) later pooled stronger data and showed Person-Centred Planning gives only small gains in choice and community use.
This tempers the 1997 hope that policy alone would create big inclusion leaps.
Navas et al. (2025) tracked adults who moved from wards to group homes and found large jumps in quality of life when staff offered daily choices.
Their result sharpens the 1997 plea: real inclusion needs choice on the ground, not just a new address.
van der Miesen et al. (2024) counted UK health studies and saw 78 % still lock out people with ID.
This hard number shows Europe still fights the very barrier Walsh (1997) flagged.
Why it matters
For you as a BCBA, the paper is a road-map of what still breaks. Use it to argue for cash for staff training, transport, and real choice routines. When you write transition plans, cite the later data: without daily decision-making, moving someone out of an institution may fail. Push teams to measure choice hours, not just placement type.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Add a ‘choice minute’ to your session: let the client pick the order, the chair, or the snack and graph it.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
People with intellectual disability share the mixed fortunes of the diverse countries in that they live, as well as the social and political changes that mark life in Europe at the close of the twentieth century. The European Union exerts its influence through common policies and centrally funded initiatives which promote the social and vocational integration of people with intellectual disabilities. At the same time, many countries in Central and Eastern Europe are building a new and as-yet untested social order. This paper outlines the distinctive features of European identity. Some of the gains already achieved on behalf of Europeans with intellectual disability are presented, as well as some of the problems which continue to threaten their well-being and inclusion. It is suggested that partnerships between countries and regions can help to chart new territory for citizens of the Old World.
Journal of intellectual disability research : JIDR, 1997 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2788.1997.tb00687.x