School & Classroom

Adapting a virtual manipulative-based instructional sequence to target maintenance.

Bassette et al. (2023) · Research in developmental disabilities 2023
★ The Verdict

Tacking an extended abstract phase onto virtual VRA lessons helps kids with autism or ID learn math, but you still need daily mixed review to lock the skill in.

✓ Read this if BCBAs teaching math to elementary students with autism or intellectual disability in public or special-ed classrooms.
✗ Skip if Practitioners working on non-academic goals or with fully verbal older students who already maintain math skills.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Bassette et al. (2023) tested a new twist on the classic VRA math sequence. They added an extra step called 'extended abstract' to make skills stick longer.

Three elementary students with autism or intellectual disability joined. The team used a multiple-baseline design across math behaviors. Kids first dragged virtual blocks, then drew pictures, then used numbers, and finally solved word problems without any props.

02

What they found

All three students learned the new math skills. Scores went up during teaching and stayed above baseline.

Maintenance was shaky. Some kids kept the skill for weeks; others needed booster shots. The extra abstract phase helped, but not evenly.

03

How this fits with other research

Vostanis et al. (2021) also taught math to students with IDD. They used daily fluency timings instead of virtual blocks. Both teams saw gains, but Vostanis got stronger maintenance. The difference: daily practice versus weekly probes.

Ulriksen et al. (2024) checked maintenance too. They taught reading to AAC users and saw steady upkeep. Their secret was short, mixed review trials baked into every lesson. Laura's team did not include that kind of spaced review.

Cariveau et al. (2016) showed that varied trials with quick 2-second gaps help skills last in DTT. Laura's virtual lessons used longer gaps and massed formats, which may explain the uneven maintenance.

04

Why it matters

If you run VRA lessons on a tablet, add the extended abstract step Laura used, but do not stop there. Build in daily mini-probes like Vostanis, mix old and new problems like Britt, and keep inter-trial intervals brief like Cariveau. That trio of tweaks should give you both acquisition and durable maintenance.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

After your last VRA lesson, add three mixed review word problems at the start of every session and keep the inter-trial interval under three seconds.

02At a glance

Intervention
direct instruction
Design
multiple baseline across behaviors
Sample size
3
Population
autism spectrum disorder, intellectual disability
Finding
positive

03Original abstract

The ability to maintain mathematical skills learned is critical for students to successfully engage in advanced mathematics and promote independence in daily living skills. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of a graduated manipulative sequence consisting of virtual, representational, abstract, and an extended abstract phase (VRAEa) to teach various types of mathematical problems to three students with autism and mild intellectual disability using a multiple probe across behavior single case design. This study extended previous research on the virtual, representational, abstract sequence (VRA) to address deficiency in maintenance results through incorporating the extended abstract phase. The results indicate the intervention was effective, however, maintenance was variable. Implications for practice and ideas for future research to support the learning needs of students with developmental disabilities are discussed.

Research in developmental disabilities, 2023 · doi:10.1016/j.ridd.2023.104488