Assessment & Research

Referential first mention in narratives by mildly mentally retarded adults.

Kernan et al. (1987) · Research in developmental disabilities 1987
★ The Verdict

Adults with mild ID give sparse and muddled first mentions, so explicitly teach how to introduce people with "a" before "the."

✓ Read this if BCBAs who write social narratives or take verbal behavior samples from adults with ID
✗ Skip if Clinicians working only with verbal, neurotypical teens

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Kelleher et al. (1987) asked adults with mild intellectual disability to retell short picture stories. They compared the stories to ones told by adults without disability.

The team counted how each group introduced a new character for the very first time. They looked for clear noun phrases like "a boy" or "the girl."

02

What they found

The adults with ID named fewer characters at all. When they did, they often used the wrong article, saying "the boy" before the boy had been introduced.

Black males with ID made fewer of these errors than other groups, but every ID speaker still lagged behind the non-disabled adults.

03

How this fits with other research

Redquest et al. (2021) later showed the same ID adult lab sample has trouble on the listening side too. They weakly use the normal "first noun = subject" rule when they hear unclear pronouns. Together the two papers map one expressive and one receptive gap.

Castañe et al. (1993) also watched adults with ID miss unclear language, but in directions, not stories. All three studies line up: mild ID equals a blind spot for linguistic ambiguity.

Perrot et al. (2021) found a similar "fewer words" pattern in autistic adults, hinting that sparse first mentions may cut across developmental disabilities.

04

Why it matters

When you ask clients with mild ID to recount an event, do not assume they will set the scene for you. Probe with "Who was there?" and model the article switch: "A man walked in. Then the man spoke." A quick script like this can raise the clarity of police interviews, medical intakes, and social-story practice.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Model the article switch: say "A cashier appeared. Then the cashier smiled" and have the client repeat with the next picture.

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
quasi experimental
Sample size
60
Population
intellectual disability, neurotypical
Finding
negative
Magnitude
medium

03Original abstract

Referential first mentions in narrative reports of a short film by 40 mildly mentally retarded adults and 20 nonretarded adults were compared. The mentally retarded sample included equal numbers of male and female, and black and white speakers. The mentally retarded speakers made significantly fewer first mentions and significantly more errors in the form of the first mentions than did nonretarded speakers. A pattern of better performance by black males than by other mentally retarded speakers was found. It is suggested that task difficulty and incomplete mastery of the use of definite and indefinite forms for encoding old and new information, rather than some global type of egocentrism, accounted for the poorer performance by mentally retarded speakers.

Research in developmental disabilities, 1987 · doi:10.1016/0891-4222(87)90019-9