Assessment & Research

Developmental disabilities and behavioral problems among school children in the Western Cape of South Africa.

Giarelli et al. (2009) · Research in developmental disabilities 2009
★ The Verdict

Half of Grade R/1 kids in this poor South African district screened positive for developmental or behavior problems, double the official count.

✓ Read this if BCBAs doing school-based screening or program design in low-income areas.
✗ Skip if Clinicians who only see fully-diagnosed clients in well-resourced private centers.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Giarelli et al. (2009) visited Grade R and Grade 1 classes in a poor rural area of South Africa’s Western Cape. They gave every child a short screening test for developmental disabilities and another for behavior problems. Teachers and parents also filled out quick checklists. The goal was to count how many kids might need extra help, not to give full diagnoses.

02

What they found

The screeners flagged 42 % of the children for possible developmental disabilities and 36 % for serious behavior problems. These numbers were twice as high as the official special-needs list kept by the schools. In plain words, half the class was struggling, but most were not on anyone’s radar.

03

How this fits with other research

Verkerk et al. (2014) followed very-low-birth-weight toddlers for two years. They showed that kids who failed two or more quick screens at age 3½ were 3.4 times more likely to need learning support at age 5½. Ellen’s snapshot lines up: early flags matter.

Foti et al. (2015) pooled data from many reading studies. They found that kids with reading disabilities also have memory and attention gaps. Ellen’s 42 % screen-positive group likely includes these children, pointing to why simple letter tests are not enough.

Faso et al. (2016) did a similar quick screen, but with adult prisoners. They found 36 % scored positive for neurodevelopmental disorders, almost matching Ellen’s 42 %. Both studies show the same grim pattern: disabilities are under-counted in poor, marginalized males, first at school, later in prison.

04

Why it matters

If you work in a low-resource school, do not trust the official special-needs list. Run a five-minute screener on every new Grade R or Grade 1 child. When you see two or more red flags, start an intervention or refer for deeper assessment. Catching kids now keeps them out of the justice system later.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Add a two-page teacher checklist to your intake packet and review results before planning any lessons.

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
survey
Sample size
174
Population
developmental delay, mixed clinical
Finding
not reported

03Original abstract

AIM: This descriptive cross-sectional study estimates the frequencies and kinds of potential developmental disabilities (DD) and behavior problems (BP) among children in grades R and 1 who attend a primary public school in rural Western Cape Province, South Africa. METHODS: Data were collected on 174 children aged 5.1-8.8 years using the Ten Question Screener (10QS) and the Developmental Behaviors Checklist-Short form. RESULTS: For the entire sample, 42% (n=73) screened positive for 1 or more possible DD on the 10SQ. Twenty-one percent (n=36) screened positive for one or more possible DDs. Thirty-six percent (n=63) of the sample scored above the cutoff for a behavioral problem that may be clinically significant. For this group the proportion of females (n=36, 39%) was slightly higher than males (n=28, 35%). CONCLUSION: The percent of possible DDs and BP among children in grades R and 1 is higher than the number of learners with special needs reported by the Principal for the entire school (18.7%). The findings from this study suggest that there may be more learners than formally designated who have special educational needs that may benefit from special educational programs (e.g. speech, occupational, language, etc.). There may be a need for expanded remedial educational and behavioral services in this school and elsewhere in the district.

Research in developmental disabilities, 2009 · doi:10.1016/j.ridd.2009.05.006