Choice and Control Within Family Relationships: The Lived Experience of Adults With Intellectual Disability.
Adults with ID see family as both safety net and cage—services must grow the client’s own voice, not just support the family.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Researchers talked with the adults who have intellectual disability. Each person lived at home with family. The team asked open questions about daily choices and control.
They held two interviews per person. Questions covered housing, money, friends, and services. The study took place in Australia.
What they found
Three clear themes came out. First, family is central. Adults trust parents or siblings to guide big decisions. Second, people recall times they spoke up for themselves. Third, they still hit walls—rules, money, or safety concerns limit real choice.
One woman said, "I want my own place, but Mum worries." A man said, "Staff decide my budget." All saw family help as both support and barrier.
How this fits with other research
Green et al. (2020) asked caregivers to rate self-determination in young adults with autism plus ID. Caregivers scored capacity low, matching the "walls" theme here. The new study gives the adult voice that the survey lacked.
Cribb et al. (2019) also used interviews with autistic youth. Those young adults felt more control when staff taught executive skills. The ID adults in Bernadette’s study rarely mentioned skill teaching—only family protection.
Bigby et al. (2009) show national spending on family support rose a large share. More services exist, yet the adults here still feel stuck. Money alone does not guarantee choice.
Why it matters
Your assessments can miss the family tightrope. Adults rely on relatives, but reliance can hide lost autonomy. Ask both client and family, "Who decides what?" Map one daily choice the adult wants back. Start a goal there. Small wins build voice.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Pick one routine (menu, bedtime, or spending). Ask the adult to set the next step; coach family to pause and let them try.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Increased choice and control is a driving force of current disability policy in Australia for people with disability and their families. Yet little is known of how adults with intellectual disability (ID) actually experience choice and control within their family relationships. We used interpretative phenomenological analysis of individual, semistructured interviews conducted with 8 Australian adults with ID to understand the meaning given to their experience of family support received around choice and decision making. Three themes were identified: (1) centrality of family, (2) experience of self-determination, and (3) limitations to choice and control. The participants identified trusted family members from whom guidance around choice and decision making was both sought and received, often involving mutual decision making and limitations to control.
Intellectual and developmental disabilities, 2018 · doi:10.1352/1934-9556-56.3.188