Assessment & Research

Brief report: Lack of correlation between age of symptom onset and contemporaneous presentation.

Tolbert et al. (2001) · Journal of autism and developmental disorders 2001
★ The Verdict

Age of first symptoms does not predict current autism severity, so treat the child in front of you, not the history book.

✓ Read this if BCBAs writing treatment plans for preschoolers with ASD
✗ Skip if Clinicians only handling adolescents or adults

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Gabriels et al. (2001) asked a simple question: does the age when autism signs first show up tell us how severe the child looks today?

They gave a short survey to parents and teachers. The survey asked for the month they first noticed symptoms and current behavior ratings.

The team then ran stats to see if earlier onset linked to worse scores now.

02

What they found

No link at all. Kids who showed signs at 12 months looked no different today from kids who showed signs at 36 months.

The correlation numbers hovered near zero for every severity scale they checked.

03

How this fits with other research

Shumway et al. (2011) asked almost the same question ten years later and got the same answer: onset pattern does not predict current functioning.

Sharp et al. (2010) seems to disagree. They found that kids with regression onset ended up more severe. The difference is focus: L looked at age, G looked at type. Age did not matter; pattern did.

Tan et al. (2021) pooled 75 studies and showed regression happens in about one third of kids, most often around 20 months. Their big numbers back the idea that onset timing alone is not useful for prognosis.

04

Why it matters

You cannot ease up on intervention just because a child showed signs late, and you cannot assume early onset means a tougher road. Base intensity on current skill data, not on the calendar month parents first worried. Update treatment plans with fresh assessments, not birth stories.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Erase any notes that say 'late onset = mild' and run a fresh VB-MAPP or AFLS instead.

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
survey
Sample size
50
Population
autism spectrum disorder
Finding
null

03Original abstract

The parents/guardians of 50 individuals were surveyed using a semistructured interview to determine the feasibility of this method and to establish ages of symptom onset. Thirty-eight informants were able to recall sufficient detail to allow categorization of the age of symptom onset. Chi-square analysis confirmed a significant association between investigators' categorization and informants' categorization. Contemporaneous presentation was indexed using Childhood Autism Rating Scale, the Autism Behavior Checklist, the Conners Hyperactivity Index, and the Ritvo-Freeman Real Life Rating Scale for Autism. No significant correlations were determined between any of these indices of symptom severity and age of symptom onset.

Journal of autism and developmental disorders, 2001 · doi:10.1023/a:1010763502253