Breast cancer screening for women with Down syndrome: lessons learned.
Routine mammograms in women with Down syndrome find cancer in fewer than one in a hundred cases—question medical necessity each time.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Chicoine et al. (2015) looked at 684 women with Down syndrome. They checked how many breast cancers were found by routine mammograms.
The team used medical records to confirm each screening result. They wanted to see if the test is worth the cost and stress for this group.
What they found
Only five women out of 684 had breast cancer detected. That is less than one in every hundred.
The authors say the yield is so low that we should question whether routine mammograms help these women.
How this fits with other research
Gregory et al. (2001) found that two-thirds of women with intellectual disability in group homes were not getting any mammograms. Brian’s paper flips the problem: even when women are screened, almost nothing is found.
Mendonca et al. (2013) showed women with intellectual and developmental disabilities are 1.5 times more likely to miss breast screening compared with other women. Brian’s data suggest that catching them up with mass screening may give little health payoff.
Son et al. (2013) warned that women with ID often over-report past tests. Brian avoided this trap by using hard medical records, making the tiny 0.7 % figure more trustworthy.
Why it matters
If you support adults with Down syndrome, ask the doctor whether a mammogram is truly needed for each woman. Balance the very small chance of finding cancer against the stress of the test and possible false alarms. Use the visit to screen for conditions that are more common in this group, such as thyroid or heart problems, and teach breast self-awareness if the woman can learn it.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Before the next medical appointment, review the woman’s file and ask the physician if a mammogram is still indicated or if resources are better spent on higher-priority health checks.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
This study examined mammogram reports of women with Down syndrome (DS) treated in the largest medical facility specifically serving adults with DS in the United States. Records of 684 women and results of 993 mammograms were reviewed, including 902 screening and 93 diagnostic mammograms. Only 2 (0.7%) women had a diagnosis of breast cancer. This study found a low rate of breast cancer among women with DS, a finding which is consistent with previous studies. The financial cost per finding was high, the benefit of the mammograms questionable, and the potential for harm greater. With less than 1% of the women with DS in this study developing breast cancer, further discussion is recommended to assess whether mammography is a beneficial, cost-effective part of health maintenance for women with DS.
Intellectual and developmental disabilities, 2015 · doi:10.1352/1934-9556-53.2.91