The effect of a fading procedure upon the acquisition of control by an overshadowed auditory feature.
Gradual fading lets a weak cue take over when a strong one is slowly removed.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Kelly et al. (1970) worked with pigeons that pecked a key for food.
A bright light on the key always came with a soft tone. The light was so strong that the birds only pecked when the light was on. The tone alone got no pecks.
The team then faded out the bright light bit by bit. They wanted to see if the tone could take over and still make the birds peck.
What they found
When the light faded slowly, the birds started pecking to the tone alone.
If the light vanished all at once, the birds stopped pecking.
Slow fading let the weak sound cue gain control.
How this fits with other research
Fovel et al. (1989) later used the same slow-fade trick with people who had severe intellectual disabilities. They faded picture cues while keeping spoken words. All three clients learned to follow the words alone. The bird result held in humans.
Palya (1985) asked: can we speed the fade up? He paid the birds for pecking during quick probe trials. The birds reached tone-only control in half the steps. The 1970 study still works, but probe pay makes it faster.
Christophersen et al. (1972) tried fading with preschool readers. They faded picture prompts while kids read aloud. Kids learned and remembered more words than with abrupt removal. Again, slow beats sudden.
Why it matters
If a client only responds to a bright picture or loud prompt, try fading it out in tiny steps. Keep the new cue, like a spoken word or smaller picture, present the whole time. Mark each small success with praise or tokens. This old pigeon lab trick still works for kids and adults who need gentler transfer of control.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Pick one prompt you usually remove fast. Break the removal into five smaller steps and reinforce each step.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Pigeons' key-pecking responses were reinforced in the presence of a compound stimulus that consisted of an auditory feature (a tone) and a visual feature (a light) and non-reinforced in the presence of a compound stimulus that was either a noise and a dark key, or noise and a light. In the condition where reinforcement trials differed from non-reinforcement trials on the basis of both auditory and visual features, the tone exerted very little control over responding on test. In the condition where reinforcement differed from non-reinforcement trials solely on the basis of the auditory features, an abrupt and a gradual introduction of the visual feature of the negative stimulus, a light, were compared for their effect upon control in the compounds. The tone acquired strong control in both cases. Evidence indicated that the tone had acquired control in the gradual condition without the occurrence of responses to the negative stimulus. An incidental finding was that when the negative stimulus consisted of a noise and a light, which was introduced abruptly, responding over the light dimension with tone, on test, was peaked at a point other than that light value used as positive and negative during training.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1970 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1970.13-179