Operant discrimination training to establish praise as a reinforcer
Praise can be built into a reinforcer in one short session, but you must keep it strong with planned backup or it will fade.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Four preschoolers with autism got a short lesson. The goal was to turn "good job" into something they would work for.
Each child sat at a table. If they picked the card that came with praise, they got a cheer. Picking the silent card gave nothing.
After many quick trials, the kids learned to choose the praise card. Researchers then checked if praise alone would keep them working.
What they found
Right after training, every child worked for praise. The new reinforcer looked strong.
Days later, the power faded. Without backup, praise stopped pulling its weight.
The team showed you can condition praise fast, but you must plan to keep it alive.
How this fits with other research
Clay et al. (2020) widens the lens. They asked which language to use. Most bilingual kids did not care if praise came in English or Spanish. Together, the papers say: first make praise a reinforcer, then pick any language the child understands.
Davis et al. (2021) seems to clash. In their study, praise failed and only a music video kept a child working. The gap is real: Lugo conditioned praise in a quiet teaching setup, while Davis tested it inside a tough high-probability sequence. Praise can be built, but it may still lose to stronger items in demanding tasks.
Wanchisen et al. (1989) set the stage. They taught us to check reinforcers often. Lugo adds the next step: if nothing works, you can create a new one through quick discrimination drills.
Why it matters
You now have a fast way to turn praise into currency. Run the card game for ten minutes, then watch if work rates rise. When the novelty fades, pair praise with tiny edibles or bubbles, then thin the backup. Keep testing weekly so you know when to boost again.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Play a five-minute card game where the only payoff is enthusiastic praise, then track if the child later works for praise alone—if not, add a tiny edible and fade it fast.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Social deficits are a hallmark feature of autism spectrum disorder (ASD). Consequently, socially mediated consequences (i.e., praise) may not function as reinforcers for individuals with ASD. Given the frequency in which praise is used as a programmed consequence in empirical research and in clinical practice, it is necessary to explore procedures that could condition praise to function as reinforcers. Operant discrimination training has emerged as a potential procedure to condition stimuli to acquire reinforcing properties. This study aimed to utilize the operant discrimination training procedure to condition a praise statement to function as a reinforcer. Four children diagnosed with ASD participated in the study. A nonconcurrent multiple baseline design across participants was used to evaluate this emerging pairing procedure. Findings suggest that immediate effects were observed across all participants, but responding did not maintain, suggesting that reinforcing value of the praise statement diminished.
Behavioral Interventions, 2017 · doi:10.1002/bin.1485