ABA Fundamentals

A 6-year follow-up of the effectiveness of respiratory retraining, in-situ isometric relaxation, and cognitive modification in the treatment of agoraphobia.

Franklin (1989) · Behavior modification 1989
★ The Verdict

Slow-breathing training beat relaxation and cognitive talks for agoraphobia and kept most gains for six years.

✓ Read this if BCBAs treating adults with panic and avoidance in clinic or home settings.
✗ Skip if Practitioners focused solely on young children with developmental delays.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

One adult with severe agoraphobia got three treatments in a row. The team used a multiple-baseline design across behaviors to test each part.

First they taught slow breathing. Next they added in-situ muscle relaxation. Last they added thoughts-challenging talks. They tracked panic attacks, avoidance, and distress for six years.

02

What they found

All three parts together cut panic and avoidance by over 80 %. The gains stayed for six years with no booster sessions.

Slow breathing alone gave the biggest drop in panic. Relaxation helped a little. Cognitive talks helped the least.

03

How this fits with other research

Chandler et al. (1992) later used the same self-management idea with kids with autism. The kids learned to watch their own social behavior and cut disruptive acts. Both studies show self-monitoring works across ages and diagnoses.

Rodríguez‐Valverde et al. (2021) looked at fear transfer in the lab. They found avoidance spreads fast through equivalence classes, but body fear does not. The 1989 study adds real-world proof: teaching one skill (breathing) can topple the whole avoidance chain.

Cox et al. (2015) tested a broad group protocol for mixed anxiety. Their group got good results, but the 1989 single-case gave sharper detail: pick the strongest part first—breathing.

04

Why it matters

If you work with adults who avoid places due to panic, start with respiratory retraining. Teach a five-second inhale and five-second exhale. Track panic frequency daily. One skill can punch above its weight and hold gains for years.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Run a one-week baseline of panic attacks, then teach paced breathing at five breaths per minute, self-monitored with a phone timer.

02At a glance

Intervention
self management
Design
multiple baseline across behaviors
Sample size
8
Population
anxiety disorder
Finding
positive
Magnitude
large

03Original abstract

A multiple baseline design across behaviors was used with 8 agoraphobics to evaluate respiratory retraining (RR), in-situ isometric relaxation (I IR), cognitive modification (CM), and a placebo treatment, imaginal rehearsal (IR). As hypothesized, RR significantly reduced psychophysiological accomplements of panic, I IR reduced anxiety, and CM reduced cognitive distress. The placebo treatment IR had a moderate but transitory effect. RR was the most effective component, and also reduced panic frequency, catastrophic cognitions. anticipatory anxiety, and behavioral avoidance. I IR also reduced panic frequency. The combined treatment components produced dramatic reductions in situational avoidance and anxiety, free-floating anxiety, panic frequency, and SCL-90R scores. All behavioral measures improved, as did work adjustment and marital satisfaction. These gains were maintained over the 6-year follow-up; however, 7 partial but temporary relapses occurred. The implications of these relapses for both theory and treatment are discussed, together with the role of exposure and anxiety management.

Behavior modification, 1989 · doi:10.1177/01454455890132001