The relationship between existing residential services and the needs of autistic adults.
Generic group homes set autistic adults up to fail unless you insist on autism-specific tweaks up front.
01Research in Context
What this study did
McClannahan et al. (1990) looked at every paper they could find on where autistic adults live. They read reports on group homes, hostels, and large institutions. They asked one question: do these places fit people with autism?
The answer was mostly no. The authors wrote that almost every home was built for people with intellectual disability, not autism. Staff ratios, noise rules, and daily schedules ignored autism needs like sensory breaks or predictable routines.
What they found
The review found a clear mismatch. Most homes expected residents to fit in, rather than changing the home to fit the resident. Staff rarely had autism training. Activities were chosen for the group, not for the individual.
Because of this, adults with autism often stayed in their rooms or had more behavior problems. The paper warned that without autism-specific design, placement could fail.
How this fits with other research
Later work tested the warning. Lerman et al. (1995) ran a real-world comparison and found that small, specialised group homes gave better quality than large sites, without costing more. Their data showed the fix is possible.
Hassin-Herman et al. (1992) and Young (2006) added detail: smaller, dispersed homes beat both institutions and cluster units on adaptive skills and staff interaction. These studies do not contradict E et al.; they show what happens when you build the right setting.
Benderix et al. (2006) gave the parent view. One family saw their autistic child calm down in a group home, yet still worried staff did not 'get' autism. The case echoes E et al.'s point: physical placement is only step one; autism knowledge must follow.
Why it matters
If you help an adult move, do not just ask 'Is there a bed?' Ask 'Is the home autism-ready?' Check for low-arousal decor, fixed daily mini-schedules you can see, and staff who can name sensory tools. Push for these tweaks before move-in; once the person is there, it is harder to change the house rules.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Add a one-page 'Autism Fit Check' to every referral packet: noise level, visual clutter, staff autism training hours, and daily schedule format.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Existing residential services for adults with autism vary in size, location, and source of funding. Most service options have been designed for individuals with handicaps other than autism and therefore have difficulty addressing the needs of all but the highest functioning autistic adults. This paper provides a review of the characteristics of autism that affect adaptation to residential settings. A description of existing residential options based on the combined experiences of Great Britain and North Carolina is presented, and directions for future research are then discussed.
Journal of autism and developmental disorders, 1990 · doi:10.1007/BF02206543