School & Classroom

Role reversals: an analysis of therapeutic effects achieved with disruptive boys during their appointments as peer monitors.

Fowler et al. (1986) · Journal of applied behavior analysis 1986
★ The Verdict

Letting disruptive students police recess rules drops their own problem behaviors instantly.

✓ Read this if BCBAs looking for fast recess fixes in elementary schools.
✗ Skip if Teams needing long-term gains without daily staff setup.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Three disruptive boys became recess cops. Each took a turn wearing a badge and handing points to classmates who followed playground rules.

The teacher showed each boy how to watch for safe, kind play and mark points on a card. Points bought candy later.

Researchers counted every negative act—hitting, yelling, rule-breaking—before, during, and after each boy’s cop week.

02

What they found

Negative acts dropped to almost zero while a boy was monitor. Two boys also started giving compliments and sharing more.

When the badge went away, bad behavior bounced back. No spill-over to regular class time was seen.

03

How this fits with other research

Lowe et al. (1995) and Jason et al. (1985) show the same peer-power idea works for kids with autism or multiple handicaps. They trained peers to start play, not police it, and saw gains last months.

Koegel et al. (1992) used video self-check instead of a badge. Both studies cut bad peer acts fast, but video added lasting self-awareness.

Renne et al. (1976) and Anger et al. (1976) used teacher tokens for the same target behaviors. Their gains held 7–12 weeks because home joined the game. The monitor role works quicker, yet fades without backup.

04

Why it matters

You can turn your toughest recess kid into a helper in one lunch break. Pick one clear rule, hand over a point card, and watch trouble drop. Keep the job short and rotate it so the effect stays fresh. Pair the badge with home points or video review if you want the gain to stick.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Name one disruptive student ‘recess deputy,’ give them a point card for safe play, and collect data for 15 minutes.

02At a glance

Intervention
token economy
Design
reversal abab
Sample size
3
Population
not specified
Finding
positive
Magnitude
large

03Original abstract

Three 7-year-old boys with histories of negative interactions were appointed to monitor individual classmates during daily noon recess. As monitors, the boys awarded points to their classmates for playing appropriately and, on rare occasions, withdrew a point for negative interactions. The three boys immediately decreased their own rates of negative interactions during the sessions in which they were appointed as monitors. Two of the boys concomitantly increased their rates of positive interactions. Their reductions in negative interactions were not maintained during reversals and did not clearly generalize to the morning or afternoon recess periods. Subsequent appointment of the boys as peer monitors during the morning recess produced similar improvements in their behavior. Results suggest that appointment to the role of peer monitor may itself function as an intervention.

Journal of applied behavior analysis, 1986 · doi:10.1901/jaba.1986.19-437