School & Classroom

"It is like you are in a golden cage": How autistic students experience special education classrooms in general high schools.

Zakai-Mashiach (2023) · Research in developmental disabilities 2023
★ The Verdict

Autistic graduates say special-ed rooms inside regular high schools can feel like gilded cages—listen to them and plan for true inclusion.

✓ Read this if BCBAs working with high-school students in self-contained ASD classrooms.
✗ Skip if Clinicians serving only preschool or adult clients.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Zakai-Mashiach (2023) talked to 12 autistic adults who had spent high school in special-ed rooms inside regular high schools.

Each person looked back and told stories about daily life, friends, and how they saw themselves.

The study used long interviews so graduates could speak in their own words.

02

What they found

Three big pains came up again and again.

First, the other students in the room were very different from each other, so making friends felt hard.

Second, kids in the rest of the school called them names like "the special class," which hurt.

Third, they felt stuck between two worlds—too "different" for regular classes but not wanting the special-ed label.

One person said, "It is like you are in a golden cage."

03

How this fits with other research

Titlestad et al. (2019) asked autistic college students what help they want now.

Those students asked for one-to-one mentors and coaches—exactly the kind of support the graduates in Zakai-Mashiach (2023) said they missed in high school.

Meuret et al. (2001) surveyed teachers in Scotland and found that regular-ed teachers were scared to include autistic students unless they had extra training.

Mati’s student voices give the other side: when schools keep autistic kids in separate rooms, the kids feel lonely and labeled.

The two studies do not clash—they simply show the same problem from teacher and student eyes.

Tyrer et al. (2009) counted staff in every state and showed that places with more aides send more kids into regular classes.

Mati’s findings hint why that matters: more aides could mean fewer "golden cages."

04

Why it matters

If you help write IEPs or run social-skills groups, ask the student directly what feels isolating.

Then add goals that push for real inclusion—like eating lunch with peers or joining one regular-ed club.

Small moves can break the cage.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Ask your student to pick one regular-ed class or club they want to try this week, then set a 15-minute peer buddy plan.

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
qualitative
Sample size
12
Population
autism spectrum disorder
Finding
not reported

03Original abstract

BACKGROUND: Students with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) often grapple with the challenges and demands of a general school environment. To date, studies have focused on inclusion within that environment, not distinguishing the experience of students in ASD special education classrooms within the general school. This study examined the retrospective perceptions of high-functioning autistic high school graduates who had been in ASD special education classrooms in general high schools to understand their experience, learn about their needs, and enhance future educational experiences. METHOD: Using interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) as a methodological framework, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 12 autistic individuals aged 19-27 that were enrolled in those particularized classrooms during high school. Data were analyzed using Thematic Analysis. RESULTS: Three overarching themes were identified: (1) the challenge of heterogeneity among students in these classrooms; (2) exclusion and labeling; and (3) identity confusion. CONCLUSIONS: The findings of this paper highlight the need for greater attention to the voices and experiences of individuals with ASD regarding this educational model of ASD special education classrooms in general schools. Participants' perceptions about their educational experience in ASD special education classrooms need to be addressed at all levels of inclusive policy and practice.

Research in developmental disabilities, 2023 · doi:10.1016/j.ridd.2022.104419