Early childhood autism and the question of egocentrism.
Autistic children were no more impaired than cognitively matched peers on visuospatial perspective-taking tasks, so the claim that autism reflects a simple Piagetian egocentrism does not hold up.
01Research in Context
What this study did
The team gave visuospatial perspective-taking tasks to three groups: autistic children, children with Down syndrome, and neurotypical children.
All kids were matched on mental age so the groups started on equal footing.
The task showed a scene from two different camera angles and asked the child to pick the photo that matched what another person could see.
What they found
Autistic children picked the correct photo just as often as the other two groups.
The result knocks down the old claim that autistic kids are stuck in an egocentric bubble.
If cognitive level is held steady, they can step out of their own viewpoint.
How this fits with other research
Hewitt et al. (2016) looked deeper and found the same accuracy, but autistic kids got there by mental rotation instead of body-matching.
Conson et al. (2015) and Armstrong et al. (2014) later saw slower egocentric transformations in adults with ASD, yet Hobson (1984) saw no speed or accuracy gap in children. The gap appears only when the task adds adult-level complexity, not in basic picture choice.
Aman et al. (1987) built on the null result by showing that once perspective-taking skill is present, its strength predicts real-life social skills better than IQ does.
Why it matters
You can drop the outdated warning that autistic clients can't understand another visual point of view. When language or cognitive demands are low, they succeed. Use simple perspective tasks to build confidence before layering on social nuance. If an older client still struggles, check for task complexity first, not a missing social sense.
What Egocentrism Means in Autism Research
In Piaget's framework, egocentrism is the failure to separate one's own viewpoint from another person's. It is often measured with visuospatial role-taking tasks that ask a child to judge how a scene looks from a different position.
Researchers proposed that this cognitive component of perspective-taking might underlie social competence, linking it to what later work would call theory of mind.
If autistic children were fundamentally egocentric, they should struggle disproportionately on these role-taking tasks compared with peers of the same cognitive level.
What the Study Found
Autistic children were not more impaired at recognizing visuospatial perspectives than typically developing children of comparable intellectual level on tests of operational thinking.
A smaller comparison suggested autistic children performed about as well as children with Down syndrome of similar verbal mental age.
These findings make it improbable that autistic children are especially egocentric in appreciating visuospatial perspectives. Clinically, assess perspective-taking directly rather than assuming a global egocentric deficit.
Get CEUs on This Topic — Free
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ on-demand CEUs including ethics, supervision, and clinical topics like this one. Plus a new live CEU every Wednesday.
Start a session with a quick three-photo perspective game: show a toy from two views and ask which photo the puppet sees; praise correct choices to build social confidence.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
An individual's social competence is often considered in terms of his role-taking abilities. In the light of studies by Piaget, it has been supposed that a child's developing capacity to appreciate the viewpoints of others in a social context is reflected in his ability to recognize points of view in a visuospatial setting. If this is valid, then visuospatial role-taking tasks may afford a measure of some relatively "cognitive" component of the capacity to engage in social behavior. Tasks in which subjects were required to make judgments about different and yet related views of a three-dimensional scene or object, together with tests of operational thinking, were presented to normal children and to subjects with the diagnosis of infantile autism. The results indicate that autistic children are not more impaired in their recognition of visuospatial perspectives than are normal children of comparable intellectual level in tests of operational thinking. A further, more limited study yielded suggestive evidence that over this series of tasks, autistic children perform as well as subjects with Down's syndrome who have a similar verbal mental age. These findings render it improbable that autistic children are especially "egocentric" in their appreciation of visuospatial perspectives.
Journal of autism and developmental disorders, 1984 · doi:10.1007/BF02408558