The relevance of metabolic rate in behavioral medicine research.
Metabolic rate is a handy warning light, not the steering wheel; pair it with behavioral skills and population-specific cut-offs.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Matthews et al. (1987) wrote a narrative review. They pulled together studies that link metabolic rate to obesity, eating disorders, smoking, and heart risk.
The paper does not test a new treatment. It maps what was known about how fast the body burns energy and how that relates to common health problems.
What they found
The review shows that metabolic rate is easy to measure and tracks with weight and heart health. It is a marker, not a behavior you can teach.
The authors warn that metabolic numbers alone cannot replace behavioral plans. You still need diet, exercise, and self-monitoring to move the needle.
How this fits with other research
Iwata et al. (1990) updates the story. Their later review says keeping weight off depends on sticking with behavioral skills, not on having a fast metabolism.
Agiovlasitis et al. (2014) seems to clash but does not. They show adults with Down syndrome need higher heart-rate index values to hit the same MET level. The 1987 paper spoke about typical adults; Stamatis adds the rule: adjust targets for disability.
Ramos-Jiménez et al. (2014) extends the idea to youth with intellectual disability. They prove simple tape-measure numbers, like waist over height, predict metabolic syndrome. The 1987 call for easy metabolic proxies finally has a ruler you can use.
Why it matters
You now know metabolic rate is only a dashboard light. Use it to flag risk, then teach behavioral skills for weight, meals, and activity. If your client has Down syndrome, borrow Stamatis numbers to set honest exercise goals. For kids with ID, add waist-height checks during intake. Measure, then move to behavior.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Add waist-to-height ratio to baseline measures for any overweight client.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
This article reviews research relating metabolism to areas of interest to behavioral medicine. Metabolic rate has been investigated as a possible mediator of a variety of problems related to energy balance. Metabolic rate has also been utilized to investigate excessive cardiac activity that may be associated with cardiovascular disease. Although resting metabolic rate does not appear to be different in obese compared with nonobese, diet-induced thermogenesis is diminished in obese subjects. Caloric restriction produces a decline in metabolic rate in both obese and nonobese and further reduces the diet-induced thermogenic effect in obese. Exercise may prevent the decline in metabolic rate following caloric restriction. Anorexic individuals have a lowered metabolic rate that appears to increase rapidly after refeeding. Although bulimic individuals who purge via self-induced vomiting do not have a lower metabolic rate than matched control subjects, the frequency of purging has been found to be inversely related to resting metabolic rate. Metabolic rate has also been investigated as a possible mediator of weight regulation in individuals who smoke cigarettes and has been shown to decrease with smoking cessation. Tissue overperfusion, or an increase in cardiovascular activity above metabolic need, has been shown to increase peripheral resistance and may lead to hypertension.
Behavior modification, 1987 · doi:10.1177/01454455870113003