Self-processing in individuals with autism spectrum disorder.
Self-processing in autism is sometimes different, sometimes not—check it before you treat it.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Nijhof et al. (2019) read every paper they could find on how people with autism think about themselves. They pulled studies on name response, mirror recognition, memory for self-actions, and brain reactions to self-faces.
The team did not run new tests. They simply mapped what is known, what is fuzzy, and where the next study should go.
What they found
The map shows a messy field. Some papers say self-processing is clearly off in autism. Others find no difference. The one firm point: we still do not know why these mixed results happen.
The authors call for lifespan work that mixes questionnaires, reaction-time tasks, and brain measures in the same people.
How this fits with other research
Two camps emerge. Robinson et al. (2017), Berna et al. (2016), and Northrup et al. (2022) all report weaker self-memory, less self-bias, or smaller brain 'pop' to self-faces. Their data feed the 'atypical' side of the review.
Yet McGarty et al. (2018) and Saldaña et al. (2009) find typical self-reference effects when IQ is matched and the task is simple perception or action monitoring. These papers seem to contradict the review’s gloomy summary.
The clash is mostly about method. Studies that control IQ and use quick lab tasks often show intact self-processing. Studies that rely on free recall or social context find deficits. The review is right: we need multi-method designs to solve the puzzle.
Why it matters
Do not assume every client with autism has a broken self-system. Add a quick self-reference trial to your intake: show the child their own photo versus a stranger’s and note response time. If they slow down or look away, target self-recognition in your social-skills program. If they react normally, spend your minutes on joint attention or conversation instead. One simple probe keeps your treatment plan aligned with real, not assumed, deficits.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Tape a photo of the client and one of a peer on the table; measure which picture the child looks at first and longest—use the result to decide if self-recognition needs treatment time.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Research attempting to explain the social difficulties observed in autism spectrum disorder has focused predominantly on difficulties understanding others, but there are indications that self-referential processing is also atypical in autism. For example, infants who later get an autism diagnosis show a reduced response when hearing their own name. In addition, research suggests that the self-bias (the tendency to preferentially process information when self-relevant) is smaller or absent in autism. However, findings are mixed: researchers are yet to clarify exactly those aspects of self-processing which are atypical in autism and in what way they are atypical. To gain further insight into these issues, future studies should focus on whether and how different aspects of self-processing are related in both neurotypical and autistic individuals. Furthermore, the (a)typical development of different aspects of the self, as well as the impact of the self on different domains of cognitive processing, deserves further attention, requiring studies with participants in a wide age range. Finally, the use of neural measures of self-processing will be invaluable, given the recent hypothesis that autistic individuals may learn to compensate for difficulties by relying on neural pathways which differ from those utilised by neurotypical individuals. Autism Res 2019, 1-5. © 2019 International Society for Autism Research, Wiley Periodicals, Inc. LAY SUMMARY: Research has indicated that individuals with autism spectrum disorder show differences in the processing of self-relevant information. However, as yet, exactly how self-processing differs in autism remains unknown. To further our understanding of the self in autism, future studies should focus on the relationship between different aspects of self-processing, investigating brain activity as well as behaviour, across a wide range of ages.
Autism research : official journal of the International Society for Autism Research, 2019 · doi:10.1002/aur.2200