Affective learning in adults with intellectual disability: an experiment using evaluative conditioning.
Adults with mild-moderate ID can learn new emotional preferences through pairing, but the feelings extinguish faster—schedule booster pairings to keep the value alive.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Blanchette et al. (2016) asked if adults with mild-moderate intellectual disability can learn to like new things through simple pairing. They used evaluative conditioning: a neutral picture was shown next to a happy face many times. Later they tested if the once-neutral picture now felt 'good'.
The team ran the same routine with typical adults for comparison. They also checked how long the new liking lasted once the happy face stopped appearing.
What they found
The adults with ID successfully learned the new emotional preference. When asked to rate the paired picture, they now chose positive words just like the typical group did.
The catch came during extinction. Once the happy face was removed, the positive feeling faded faster in the ID group. Their new liking needed more booster pairings to stick.
How this fits with other research
Nijs et al. (2016) ran a similar 2016 lab study and saw the opposite picture: the same ID adults failed badly on facial-emotion recognition tasks. Together the papers show a task-dependent strength—forming new affect works, but reading faces stays hard.
Ohan et al. (2015) systematic review backs this up, finding large, consistent emotion-recognition deficits across many studies. The target study extends that work by proving the learning mechanism itself is intact; the bottleneck is in recognition, not acquisition.
Older work by McGrother et al. (1996) already linked lower IQ to poorer emotion ID. I et al. now add that IQ does not block new emotional learning—it only speeds extinction, a detail that updates earlier views.
Why it matters
You can build reinforcers for adults with mild-moderate ID by pairing neutral items with already-liked stimuli. Use this to create new rewards for vocational or daily-living tasks. Plan brief booster sessions so the fresh value does not fade. Do not assume slow emotion recognition means slow emotion learning—keep teaching both skills separately.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Pick one neutral work material, pair it with a known liked song for five brief trials, then reassess preference next week and re-pair if the rating drops.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
BACKGROUND: Evaluative conditioning is a form of affective learning in which initially neutral stimuli acquire an affective value through association with negative or positive stimuli. Recent research shows an important role for cognitive resources in this type of learning. This form of affective learning has rarely been studied in intellectual disability (ID). METHOD: We examined evaluative conditioning in 16 adults with mild to moderate ID compared to age- and gender-matched control participants. Neutral shapes and symbols were repeatedly paired with positive, neutral or negative unconditioned stimuli (faces or International Affective Picture System images). There was also an extinction phase. RESULTS: There was significant acquisition of conditioning in both groups. Stimuli paired with positive images were evaluated more positively, and stimuli paired with negative images were evaluated more negatively. Post-extinction ratings however show that these novel affective associations were not maintained by individuals with ID as much as by individuals in the control group. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that ID modulates some aspects of affective learning but not necessarily initial preference acquisition.
Journal of intellectual disability research : JIDR, 2016 · doi:10.1111/jir.12246