ABA Fundamentals

TEMPORAL ALTERNATION IN THE WHITE RAT.

KEEHN (1965) · Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior 1965
★ The Verdict

Animals time their start based on upcoming work size—use this to spot and reduce long pauses in high-effort tasks.

✓ Read this if BCBAs running fixed-ratio or token boards with children who show long start-up delays.
✗ Skip if Clinicians using only time-based or response-independent schedules.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

The team worked with white rats in a small lab box.

They switched the rats between two fixed-ratio schedules in the same session.

One schedule needed 10 lever presses for food. The other needed 40.

They timed how long the rats paused after each food pellet before starting again.

02

What they found

Rats quickly learned to wait longer before the bigger 40-response schedule.

They paused about three times longer before the 40-response ratio than before the 10-response ratio.

The animals were reading the upcoming work load and adjusting their start time.

03

How this fits with other research

Halpern et al. (1966) ran the same test in pigeons and saw the same longer pauses for bigger ratios. This direct replication shows the pause-size link holds across species.

Dove et al. (1974) later showed that this pause habit carries forward. Pigeons that first learned big-ratio pauses later ran faster under simple time-based schedules. The pause pattern stuck even when the schedule changed.

Arnett (1972) looked like a contradiction. That study found extra clock cues made pigeons pause longer on fixed-interval schedules. But the pause grew because the birds waited for the cue, not because the schedule demanded more work. The two studies differ in what controls the pause: upcoming work size versus external signals.

04

Why it matters

Your learners may also pause longer when they sense a bigger task ahead. Watch for this natural timing. If you see long pauses before high-response tasks, consider breaking the task into smaller chunks or adding prompts to restart sooner. This keeps momentum and reduces avoidance.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Count the seconds each learner waits before starting a 10-token board versus a 2-token board; if the gap is large, insert a quick prompt or break the big task into smaller sets.

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
single case other
Sample size
8
Population
other
Finding
positive

03Original abstract

Four white rats were reinforced after 15 then 45 then 15 then 135 (or 5) responses to a bar under a single exteroceptive stimulus condition. Three came to make long pauses before the longest ratio in the schedule but not before any of the others. Four other rats were reinforced after alternate response chains each made on two bars. The first chain was FR5FR5 for all subjects, the second FR5FR40 for two, and FR40FR5 and FR20FR5 for one subject each. Subjects reinforced on schedule mix (chain FR5FR5 chain FR5FR40) both paused longer after the first than after the second chain relatively early in training. Later, the subject reinforced on mix (chain FR5FR5 chain FR40FR5) also paused longer after the first chain, but pauses of the fourth subject were equally short after both chains. When the ratios in the second chain were reversed the two subjects now reinforced on mix (chain FR5FR5 chain FR40FR5) paused much longer after the first chain, but the other two paused only slightly longer after the first than after the second chain.

Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1965 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1965.8-161