ERRORLESS ESTABLISHMENT OF VISUAL DISCRIMINATION USING FADING PROCEDURES.
Fade extra cues like brightness to teach visual tasks with almost no errors, but switch to delayed prompting for autistic learners doing picture work.
01Research in Context
What this study did
MOORHEARSKELLEHER et al. (1964) worked with preschool kids who did not have disabilities. The team wanted the children to pick a shape, not a bright spot.
They first made the correct card much brighter. Bit by bit they cut the brightness while keeping the shape the same. The kids kept choosing correctly even after the brightness cue was gone.
What they found
Almost every child learned the shape game with almost zero wrong picks. Fading the bright prompt let the shape alone control the child’s choice.
How this fits with other research
Fields (1978) repeated the same trick with pigeons and got the same clean transfer, showing the rule works across species. Berkowitz (1990) flipped the story with autistic learners: when pictures were the target, fading prompts took more trials and caused more errors than delayed prompting. The kids with autism did better when the teacher waited instead of fading.
Harrison et al. (1975) added a twist: even after errorless training, the birds still treated the non-shape cue as a stop signal, so inhibition can still form. Emmelkamp et al. (1986) later used fading to move control away from harmful restraint tubes to simple wristbands, cutting self-injury in teens with profound ID.
Why it matters
Use brightness fading when you need errorless acquisition of a visual task with young neurotypical clients. If you work with autistic learners, think twice: try delayed prompting first for picture or PECS tasks. Either way, move prompts slowly and measure both errors and problem behavior so you know when to switch tactics.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Start a shape-matching game with one extra-bright correct card, then dim it 10% each trial until only the shape remains.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
A visual discrimination task involved presenting a triangle briefly as a sample. When it was withdrawn, this triangle and two others differing slightly in degree of rotation were presented in different positions, with S required to locate the sample that had been presented. Discrimination proved difficult for preschool children. When only the correct triangle was illuminated, discrimination was readily established. The brightness difference between correct and incorrect matches was gradually faded out by increasing the intensity of the incorrect matches, until they were equal in brightness to the correct match. The discrimination established by brightness difference was maintained in its absence, thereby transferring stimulus control from brightness to form, in an almost errorless sequence.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1964 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1964.7-269