The role of community nurses and residential staff in supporting women with intellectual disability to access breast screening services.
Staff training gaps block breast screening for women with ID, and simple classes do not fix it.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Matson et al. (2011) talked with community nurses and residential staff who support women with intellectual disability.
The team asked what makes it hard for these women to get breast-screening appointments.
They used open interviews so staff could speak freely about real-life problems.
What they found
Staff said they lack training on cancer facts and on how to explain the test.
They listed many barriers: fear, transport, long waits, and no easy-read info.
Women miss scans because staff themselves feel unsure and unsupported.
How this fits with other research
Amore et al. (2011) asked similar staff the same year and also found “minimal cancer-prevention training.” The two studies match perfectly.
Goodwin et al. (2012) then asked the women themselves and showed most did not even know what a mammogram is. This extends the problem beyond staff to the women.
Murphy et al. (2014) interviewed families and uncovered a new layer: relatives avoid the topic because they fear tough cancer decisions. Together the four papers form one clear story.
Elmadani et al. (2024) reviewed education trials and found only tiny knowledge gains and no rise in actual screening uptake. Their wide lens confirms that short classes alone do not fix the deep barriers first mapped by Matson et al. (2011).
Why it matters
You now have a full picture: staff feel lost, women stay unaware, families stay silent, and quick classes fail. Use this map to build stronger support. Start by writing a one-page easy-read script that staff can rehearse with each woman. Pair it with a short role-play so staff practice calming fear and booking transport. Track real appointments, not quiz scores.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Hand your team a laminated easy-read mammogram story and run a 5-minute role-play on how to book the ride and calm nerves.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
BACKGROUND: Women with intellectual disability (ID) are surviving to the age group at greatest risk of developing breast cancer (50-69 years). These women are more likely to experience a greater number of risk factors placing them at an advanced threat of developing breast cancer. However, as a result of cognitive deficits and communication difficulties these women are dependent upon staff to support them to attend the breast screening clinics. AIM: The aim of this paper was to examine how community nurses and residential staff support women with ID to access breast screening services. METHODOLOGY: Six focus groups were held with community nurses and residential staff who work in the field of ID in one region of the UK. The focus groups were tape recorded and the transcriptions were subjected to a thematic content analysis. FINDINGS: Although many of the participants recognised the risk factors and signs/symptoms of breast cancer, there was still a deficit of knowledge. Both positive and negative experiences of women with ID attending for breast screening were reported; however, greater discussion focused on the latter. The participants identified 'a lack of health educational material' and also negative 'emotions, attitudes and physical barriers' as inhibiting factors for attendance. DISCUSSION: This paper highlights the need for developing a health promotion programme for women with ID focusing on breast awareness and information on screening, and also healthier lifestyles. Breast awareness via visual checks was identified for women with ID who refused to attend the breast clinics; however, issues of informed 'consent' and 'vulnerability' were raised for staff and also family carers having to undertake these checks. Development of user-friendly health educational literature using 'pictures, symbols, signs' and simplified words should be accessible to all ID staff, healthcare staff, and also women with ID.
Journal of intellectual disability research : JIDR, 2011 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2788.2010.01345.x