School & Classroom

Introduction to the Special Issue Teacher Educators for Children with Behavioral Disorders (TECBD) Conference.

Mathur et al. (2020) · Education & treatment of children 2020
★ The Verdict

Teachers give more negative feedback to Black students even when behavior is the same - audit your feedback for racial bias.

✓ Read this if BCBAs working with teachers in school settings
✗ Skip if BCBAs who only work in clinics or homes

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Patton et al. (2020) looked at how teachers give feedback to students. They compared Black and White teachers. They watched the same kids behave the same way.

The study checked if teachers gave different feedback based on the student's race.

02

What they found

Both Black and White teachers gave more negative feedback to Black students. This happened even when the students behaved the same.

The teachers did not give more negative feedback to White students for the same behaviors.

03

How this fits with other research

Neely et al. (2020) found that culturally adapted training helps teachers. Their study showed teachers improved after learning about Latinx culture. This extends R et al.'s work by showing a solution.

Striefel et al. (1974) showed that simple feedback can reduce problem behavior. But R et al. shows this feedback might be unfair to Black students. The papers seem to disagree, but they don't. S et al. looked at whether feedback works. R et al. looked at whether it's fair.

Green et al. (1975) used token economies to make teachers give more positive comments. This is important because R et al. found teachers give too many negative comments to Black students.

04

Why it matters

You might be giving more negative feedback to Black students without knowing it. Track your feedback for one week. Count how many positive and negative comments you give to each student. Compare by race. If you see a pattern, try the fixes from Neely et al. (2020) and Green et al. (1975). Add cultural context to your training. Use token systems to balance your feedback. Your words shape student behavior and self-image.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Count your positive and negative comments to each student for one day, then compare by race to spot bias.

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
other
Sample size
82
Population
not specified
Finding
negative

03Original abstract

There is a long and persistent gap between the academic achievement of White and Black students in America's schools. Further, Black students are suspended from school at a rate that is more than three times greater than White students. While there has been some suggestion that perhaps teacher-student racial matching may be part of a solution, the research does not currently provide adequate support for teacher race alone to be sufficiently effective. This study analyzed 41 Black and White teacher-student dyad mixes in elementary schools and another 41 in a high school to examine how teacher and student race interact in terms of teacher and student behaviors. While Black students were slightly more likely to be off-task and disruptive, both Black and White teachers were found to provide significantly more negative feedback to Black students regardless of their behavior. Implications for teacher practice and future study are discussed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).

Education & treatment of children, 2020 · doi:10.1037/spq0000251