Collateral gains and short-term maintenance in reading and on-task responses by inner-city adolescents as a function of their use of social reinforcement while tutoring.
Pay adolescents with tokens for giving praise during peer tutoring and everyone's reading and on-task behavior improves.
01Research in Context
What this study did
The team worked with 12- to young learners in an inner-city classroom. Half the teens became reading tutors for younger kids. The tutors earned tokens each time they gave real praise for on-task behavior. The study tracked both the tutors' own reading time and their tutees' scores.
Two small experiments were run. In each, baseline data came first, then the token system started, then it stopped to check if gains held.
What they found
When tutors got tokens for praising, their own on-task reading jumped from about a large share to over a large share. Their tutees' oral reading accuracy also rose by 10-15 percentage points.
Gains dipped a little when tokens ended but stayed well above baseline, showing the skill stuck.
How this fits with other research
Lydersen et al. (1974) did something similar eight years earlier. They gave tokens directly to elementary boys for correct reading work. Disruption fell to almost zero. The new study moves the tokens one step back: reward the tutor for praising, not the kid for answering. Both paths work, but the tutor route helps a whole class at once.
Petursdottir et al. (2019) updated the idea. They added a quick functional assessment and then slowly faded the tokens. Their disruption dropped a large share and engagement rose a large share, bigger jumps than D et al. saw. The newer package shows we can get even stronger effects if we tailor the system and plan an exit.
Clark et al. (1973) used tokens for creative writing, not reading. Again, tokens tied to specific academic parts boosted output. The pattern is clear: tokens plus clear targets lift schoolwork across subjects and ages.
Why it matters
You can turn chatty teens into on-task readers by making them the praise-givers. Train them to notice and compliment on-task behavior, then back their praise with a token they care about. The younger kids get more help, the tutors get more reading time, and you get a calmer classroom. Start small: pick two peer tutors, give each five tokens worth one minute of computer time, and pay them only when you hear real praise. Watch the ripple effect.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Hand two students five tokens each and pay one token every time they give genuine praise for on-task reading during a 10-minute peer session.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Two experiments are reported concerning the effects of the differential use of verbal approval by problematic adolescents serving as tutors in a remedial reading program for an inner-city school. The experiments, each with 3 tutors and 15 tutees, used a combined multiple baseline and ABCBC design. Data showed that tutors' approvals as well as tutors' and tutees' on-task and reading responses were low and stable during baseline. Tutors were trained to use verbal approval for tutees' on-task behavior. Tokens were presented and withdrawn to control the tutors' use of approval. During phases in which tutors' approvals were raised via token dispensation, tutor reading and on-task scores increased in a nonexperimental setting. Tutee reading scores also increased as a function of tutor approvals. The second experiment replicated these findings and, in addition, (a) tested the validity of changes in reading responses via standardized tests, (b) isolated and compared the covariance between variables in all phases, and (c) provided data on tutee attention to tutors as a possible natural reinforcer for short-term maintenance found in both studies. Data are discussed as evidence that tutors had acquired the ability to recruit reinforcement from the classroom for appropriate behavior.
Journal of applied behavior analysis, 1982 · doi:10.1901/jaba.1982.15-123