Diagnosis of depression in people with severe/profound intellectual disability.
Use the Marston checklist to flag possible depression in severe ID, then pair findings with DSM criteria and clinical judgment.
01Research in Context
What this study did
The team looked at adults with severe or profound intellectual disability. They wanted to see if the Marston 30-item checklist could spot depression.
Each person was rated on the checklist and on DSM-III-R rules. The goal was to check if behavioral signs line up with formal mood criteria.
What they found
Scores on the Marston checklist matched the DSM-III-R list for major depression. This means things like social withdrawal or sleep change can act as red flags.
The study says these depressive equivalents are useful, but they must sit next to clinical judgment, not replace it.
How this fits with other research
Martin et al. (1997) first mapped how classic mood symptoms fade and behavioral signs grow as ID deepens. Imam (2001) gives a tool to capture those signs.
LeBlanc et al. (2003) later found that aggression and self-injury did not cluster with depression in their sample. They tell clinicians to stick to core DSM mood items. The two papers seem to clash, but they looked at different groups and different checklists. Imam (2001) kept the link loose, calling equivalents helpers, not proof.
Matson et al. (2008) widened the idea to older adults using the interRAI ID form and still saw value in behavioral cues. The message across years: use extra signs, yet always pair them with standard criteria and a full clinical picture.
Why it matters
If your client has little or no speech, you cannot rely on I feel sad statements. This paper tells you to watch for clear behavior shifts and record them on a checklist. Bring those data to the psychiatrist or BCBA review, but keep DSM criteria in the center. The takeaway is practical: track sleep, appetite, activity, and social interest every shift; note big drops; share the pattern with the team before assuming depression is the cause.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Add a quick four-item sleep-appetite-activity-social log to your daily data sheet and review weekly trends.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
The Marston 30 Symptoms Checklist for detecting depression was used to determine whether or not the notion of 'depressive equivalents' can provide a few of the core characteristics necessary for the diagnosis of depressive disorders in people with severe/profound intellectual disability (ID). Diagnoses of major depression were made by a psychiatrist using the DSM-III-R criteria, combined with information from records, staff, team, parents, behaviour profiles, direct observations, mental status and follow-up visits. Twenty-two people with ID fulfilled the selection criteria from a larger sample of 150 patients who had been evaluated in 350 contact visits. Scores on the checklist for major depression for 15 subjects with severe/profound ID were similar to the core characteristics for diagnosis of major depression by DSM-III-R criteria. Evidence was found for the presence of depressive equivalents in the subjects, but these appeared to be secondary. The 15 participants with severe/profound ID were observed mostly during the depressive phase of bipolar I and bipolar II disorder, and major depression, recurrent type. Melancholic features were prominent in their presentation. Further studies of people with ID are needed to determine whether depressive equivalents are more prominent in cases of major depression with atypical features than in cases of major depression with melancholic features.
Journal of intellectual disability research : JIDR, 2001 · doi:10.1046/j.1365-2788.2001.00333.x