The token economy: a decade later.
Token economies still fail for the same 1982 reasons—poor staff training and weak maintenance—so use today’s checklists and manuals to dodge those traps.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Weitz (1982) looked back at ten years of token-economy studies. The paper pulls together what worked, what broke, and what slowed adoption in hospitals, schools, and clinics.
It is a story-style review, not a lab study. The author scanned journals from 1972 to 1982 and grouped the lessons into themes.
What they found
Token economies kept showing strong gains across ages and diagnoses. The big news was not new data—it was the roadblocks. Staff training, fading plans, and keeping the system alive after grant money ended were the repeating headaches.
Programs that skipped those steps usually collapsed once the extra staff or tokens disappeared.
How this fits with other research
Alba et al. (1972) set the stage by saying "tokens work, but generalization is missing." Weitz (1982) answers a decade later: "still missing, and here is why."
degli Espinosa et al. (2024) now gives a step-by-step checklist that replaces the 1982 worries with today’s best-practice guide. Think of it as an upgrade: same tool, clearer manual.
Ivy et al. (2017) looked at 96 recent studies and found most still leave out key details. So the 1982 warning about sloppy setup is alive in 2017 data.
Gutierrez et al. (2020) offers a fix: a short manual can train new staff to run a token economy with no extra workshops. This tackles the staff-training barrier the 1982 paper flagged.
Why it matters
If your tokens fade and the behavior fades with them, you are repeating a 40-year-old mistake. Use the 2024 checklist to build the system right from day one. Write your backup reinforcers, exchange rate, and thinning plan before the first token leaves your hand. Train staff with a printed manual, not word of mouth. These two moves solve the top killers the 1982 review spotted and keep your token economy alive long after the stickers run out.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Hand your team the one-page token-economy checklist from degli Espinosa et al. (2024) and review each component before session starts.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
In the last decade, the token economy has been extended widely across populations and behaviors in treatment, rehabilitation, educational, and community settings. Outcome research has expanded as well to include large-scale program evaluations and comparative and combined treatment studies of the token economy. In a previous review (Kazdin & Bootzin, 1972), several obstacles were identified for the effective application of the token economy. These included identifying procedures to enhance program efficacy, to train staff, to overcome client resistance, and to promote long-term maintenance and transfer of training. The present paper discusses recent advances in research and reviews progress on the major issues identified previously. New issues have become salient in the last decade that pertain to the extension of the token economy to institutional settings. The demands for maintaining the integrity of treatment, the ability to integrate token economies within existing institutional constraints, and the disseminability of the procedures on a large scale are major issues that may dictate the future of the token economy.
Journal of applied behavior analysis, 1982 · doi:10.1901/jaba.1982.15-431