The effect of multiple S-delta periods on responding on a fixed-interval schedule: 3. Effect of changes in pattern of interruptions, parameters and stimuli.
Fixed-interval scallops survive lots of short extinction breaks, so schedule control does not need steady mediating behavior.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Pigeons pecked a key on a fixed-interval 5-min schedule. Food arrived only for the first peck after 5 min passed.
During each interval the experimenter turned the lights off for several short S-delta periods. The birds could not earn food while the lights were out.
What they found
The birds still showed the smooth scallop shape: low pecks early, fast pecks near food time. Extra dark periods did not flatten the curve.
The pattern stayed the same no matter how many or how long the S-delta breaks were. The schedule itself, not steady mediating behavior, controlled the timing.
How this fits with other research
Palya (1993) extended the idea. He mapped different colored lights to early, middle, and late parts of the same fixed interval. Early colors acted like negative reinforcers and late colors like positive reinforcers, showing that time within the interval gives stimuli their power.
O'leary et al. (1969) used second-order schedules where brief food-paired flashes marked the end of small FI parts. The flashes kept the scalloped pattern even when real food was far away, echoing DEWS (1965) that brief cues can hold the shape.
Iversen et al. (1984) looked at schedule-induced activity instead of key pecks. Visual cues signaling food versus no-food periods controlled the extra movement, broadening the rule: schedule-linked stimuli guide many kinds of behavior.
Why it matters
You can stop worrying that every second must be filled with reinforcement. Brief breaks, room lights off, or short extinction periods will not wreck the timing your learner has built. Use clear signals for when reinforcement is possible and when it is not, then trust the schedule to keep the rhythm.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Insert brief 10-s blackout periods during a client's FI schedule; watch the scallop stay intact.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Pigeons responding under fixed-interval schedules of reinforcement were interrupted by S(Delta) periods during the course of the intervals. Whether intervals were interrupted by 1, 2, or 5 S(Delta) periods, the general scalloped pattern of FI responding persisted. Parameter values up to 27(3/4) hr for the FI and 2(3/4) hr for the individual S(Delta) interruptions were studied. The results further weaken the hypothesis that the FI pattern of responding depends crucially on control of responding by continuously chained mediating behavior.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1965 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1965.8-427