Stimulus stringing by pigeons.
Pigeons can learn and transfer a four-step color sequence, proving chaining works even when every cue is swapped.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Researchers taught pigeons to peck four colors in a set order.
Each bird saw a row of four colored disks. They had to peck, say, red-blue-green-yellow in that exact order to get grain.
After the birds mastered one four-color chain, the team swapped in new colors. They wanted to see if the pigeons could still keep the sequence straight.
What they found
The birds quickly learned the first four-step color chain.
When new colors appeared, accuracy stayed high. The pigeons were not just memorizing one picture; they had learned the rule "peck four colors in order."
The result shows pigeons can master and transfer an arbitrary four-item chain.
How this fits with other research
NEVIN et al. (1963) showed pigeons can build their own two-step chain to meet a delay rule. Wesp et al. (1981) moved further, proving birds can learn an experimenter-made four-step color chain and use it with new colors.
Hall (1992) looks like a contradiction at first. That study rewarded pigeons for changing their four-peck order every trial, producing near-random sequences. Wesp et al. (1981) got the opposite: stable, fixed orders. The difference is the payoff rule. When novelty pays, birds vary; when sameness pays, birds lock in.
Shimp (1976) adds that pigeons remember their own recent peck order for a few seconds. Wesp et al. (1981) stretches that window, showing birds can hold an imposed four-color order long enough to finish the chain.
Why it matters
If you teach chained tasks—such as hand-washing, dressing, or multi-step academics—this study is a reminder that learners can grasp long, arbitrary sequences and still use the rule when materials change. Break the chain into clear, colored or otherwise marked stimuli, reinforce each link, and then test with new items to show the learner the rule still applies.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Color-code the four steps of a dressing chain, reinforce in order, then swap shirt colors to check transfer.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Pigeons were trained to peck one, two, three, and then four colors in a predetermined sequence from a five-key array where, over trials, each color appeared equally often in each position of the array. Incorrect pecks resulted in a buzzer and trial termination, with the same array presented for the next trial. Correct pecks produced feedback and correct strings could produce food. All subjects performed at a high level of accuracy with no difference at asymptote between a continuous and a mixed spectral sequence as the required order. Transfer to a new set of arrays had little effect on accuracy. Errors forward in the sequence had the highest probability, followed by repeat errors, backward errors, and dark-key errors. Some arrays had a higher level of accuracy than others but a corresponding systematic variable could not be identified.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1981 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1981.36-267