On the minimal conditions for the development of a peak-shift and inhibitory stimulus control.
A 3-min break after massed extinction is enough to produce peak-shift and strong inhibitory stimulus control.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Brinker et al. (1975) worked with pigeons that had learned to peck a key for food. First they gave massed extinction until pecking almost stopped. Then they added a quick 3-minute break with one of three simple changes: food again, no food, or free food with no peck needed.
After the short break they tested how the birds responded to colors close to the training color. They wanted to know if this tiny event could create peak-shift and strong inhibitory control without long contrast histories.
What they found
Every 3-minute change produced peak-shift. The birds pecked most at a color pulled away from the original training color. They also showed strong inhibition near the old unreinforced color.
The result was the same whether the break gave food, no food, or free food. Just stopping extinction for three minutes was enough to sharpen stimulus control.
How this fits with other research
Baer (1974) showed that massed extinction alone can steepen generalization gradients. P et al. add one small step: a 3-min interpolated event right after extinction. This tiny pause flips the gradient into a peak-shift.
Schmidt et al. (1969) got peak-shift by making reinforcement duration cues stand out during training. P et al. prove you do not need fancy training. A short break after extinction does the job.
Ginsburg et al. (1971) found that longer extinction creates bigger contrast. P et al. show the opposite angle: after extinction, even a brief change can reset control.
Why it matters
You can create clear peak-shift and tight stimulus control without extra training or long contrast histories. After an extinction session, simply insert a brief change of any kind—maybe a quick snack break or a shift to non-contingent reinforcement. This small move can sharpen discrimination and reduce errors when you probe new stimuli. Try it next time you need to tighten stimulus control fast.
Get CEUs on This Topic — Free
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ on-demand CEUs including ethics, supervision, and clinical topics like this one. Plus a new live CEU every Wednesday.
After an extinction block, give a 3-min break with any stimulus change, then probe the gradient.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Failures to obtain a peak-shift and inhibitory stimulus control following massed extinction in the presence of intra- and interdimensional stimuli confirm earlier results reported by Honig, Thomas, and Guttman (1959) and by Weisman and Palmer (1969). Peak-shifts and inhibitory stimulus control were observed when any of the following procedures intervened for 3 min between massed extinction and generalization testing: (1) S+ presented, responding reinforced; (2) S+ presented, responding not reinforced; or, (3) noncontingent food presented in the presence of a dark key. Behavioral contrast was shown not to be a necessary antecedent for the occurrence of peak-shift or inhibitory stimulus control.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1975 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1975.23-385