Meaning and Verbal Behavior in Skinner's Work from 1934 to 1957.
Meaning is not inside words—it is the environment that makes the words happen.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Amalia et al. traced how Skinner changed his mind about meaning between 1934 and 1957.
They read every paper, note, and letter Skinner wrote in those years.
The authors show that in 1945 Skinner stopped asking "What does this word mean?" and started asking "What makes a person say this word now?"
What they found
Skinner flipped the problem upside-down. Instead of meaning living inside words, meaning lives in the three-term contingency: the setting, the response, and what follows it.
Words do not carry meaning like a suitcase. The environment carries the meaning, and the word is just the behavior that pops out.
How this fits with other research
Moss (2009) gives you the raw notes from Skinner’s 1947 course right after the flip happened. Those notes let you watch the new idea being taught for the first time.
Abbott (2013) repeats the same move for today’s jargon. Stop fighting over the "real" definition of "mand" and look at what contingencies make you say "mand" in the clinic.
Vargas (2013) adds the next layer: form matters only because the verbal community taught us to react to it. The 1945 shift is the base; form-versus-function is the roof.
Freeman et al. (2015) turns the 1945 insight into a lesson plan. PEAK lessons teach kids with autism the same way: control the environment, not the dictionary.
Why it matters
When a client keeps saying "I’m anxious," stop digging for the hidden feeling. Ask what happened right before the word and what happens after. Change the triggers or the consequences and the word may drop out. Skinner’s 1945 lens keeps you focused on what you can actually measure and change.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Write the ABC next time a client says a new word—treat the word as behavior, not a message.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
This paper explores the historical development of Skinner's treatment of meaning from 1930 to 1957. Twelve papers published between 1934 and 1957, and parts of The Behavior of Organisms and Science and Human Behavior related to verbal behavior, were analyzed. Before 1945 meaning was taken as a property of the verbal response, and from 1945 on, meaning was supposed to be found among the determiners of a verbal response. We argue that these different conceptions of meaning were related to distinct aspects of Skinner's explanatory system. Finally, the notion of meaning presented by Skinner in 1945 is related to the theoretical breakthrough represented by Skinner's assertion of the three-term contingency. This idea permitted verbal behavior to be analyzed in terms of its functions.
The Analysis of verbal behavior, 2005 · doi:10.1007/BF03393018