ABA Fundamentals

Effects of an oral hygiene punishment procedure on chronic rumination and collateral behaviors in monozygous twins.

Singh et al. (1982) · Journal of applied behavior analysis 1982
★ The Verdict

A quick mouthwash-plus-brush after each ruminating episode drove the behavior to near zero and the effect lasted at least six months.

✓ Read this if BCBAs treating rumination or other oral stereotypies in children or adults with severe ID.
✗ Skip if Practitioners whose settings ban any punishment-based procedures.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Two identical twin boys with severe intellectual disability kept bringing food back up and re-chewing it. This is called rumination. It can cause weight loss and even death.

The team used a simple punishment. After each episode, staff gave the boys a sip of mouthwash and brushed their teeth for two minutes. They tracked ruminations across the day using a multiple-baseline design.

02

What they found

Rumination dropped to almost zero for both twins within days. The low level held for six months with no extra training.

Good behaviors like playing and eating went up at the same time. Staff needed only a bottle of mouthwash and a toothbrush.

03

How this fits with other research

Goldman et al. (1979) tried the same mouthwash routine three years earlier, but they also let two adults eat until full. Both studies wiped out rumination, so the food add-on may be optional.

Migan‐Gandonou et al. (2020) later swapped the brush for plain mouthwash and kept the gains for four years in a child with autism. This longer follow-up shows the effect can outlive the twins’ six-month mark.

Foster et al. (1979) compared overcorrection, time-out, and DRO for other oral stereotypies. Overcorrection worked fastest, but the mouthwash method is quicker to give and less intrusive.

04

Why it matters

If you work with clients who ruminate, keep a small cup of alcohol-free mouthwash and a spare toothbrush handy. One two-minute application after the first episode can stop the cycle before medical problems start. Track for one week; most clients show a sharp drop by day three.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Place a bottle of alcohol-free mouthwash and a soft toothbrush in the client’s area; apply for two minutes right after the first ruminating episode and graph the results.

02At a glance

Intervention
other
Design
multiple baseline across participants
Sample size
2
Population
intellectual disability
Finding
strongly positive
Magnitude
very large

03Original abstract

This study investigated the suppressive effects of an oral hygiene punishment procedure on the ruminative behavior of profoundly retarded monozygous twins. Rumination, fingers in mouth/tongue out, appropriate behavior, and stereotyped behavior were measured before and during treatment with oral hygiene. Treatment was introduced for each meal in succession across the twins in a multiple-baseline design. Results showed that the rate of rumination of both twins was dramatically reduced to very low levels and stereotyped behavior increased spontaneously with the introduction of oral hygiene. Maintenance data showed that response reduction was maintained over a six-month period and, when compared to baseline levels, increased rates of socially appropriate behavior were evident in both children.

Journal of applied behavior analysis, 1982 · doi:10.1901/jaba.1982.15-309