Effects of acute and chronic morphine on delay discounting in pigeons.
Morphine withdrawal, not the drug itself, persistently pushes pigeons to choose larger delayed rewards — a clue to watch for shifting impulsivity in opioid users.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Bigham et al. (2013) gave pigeons choices between a small food reward now or a larger one later. They first tested the birds sober to see each bird's baseline preference. Then they gave the birds morphine in two ways: a single shot (acute) or daily doses for several weeks (chronic). After each drug condition they ran more choice trials. Finally they watched what happened when the drug was stopped (withdrawal).
What they found
One dose of morphine made the birds pick the small-quick reward more often. Daily morphine produced mixed results; some birds stayed impulsive, others returned toward baseline. When the drug was removed, every bird flipped: they now preferred the big delayed reward, even if they had to wait. The withdrawal effect outlasted the drug sessions by days.
How this fits with other research
Lerner et al. (2012) ran a similar pigeon study but used nicotine instead of morphine and tested memory, not delay choices. Both papers show that acute and chronic drug regimens can be compared within single subjects. Bordi et al. (1990) also gave pigeons drugs (diazepam, pentobarbital, amphetamine) and saw mixed, bird-specific changes in key-peck rates, matching the mixed chronic morphine data here.
Renda et al. (2015) looks contradictory at first: working-memory training in rats did NOT change their delay discounting, hinting that impulsive choice is hard to budge. Yet K et al. show withdrawal clearly shifted preference. The difference is method: training a cognitive skill is not the same as removing a drug that alters reward value. The rat paper warns us that not every intervention touches discounting; the pigeon paper shows that drug history can.
Miller (1976) showed pigeons' choices follow matching-law equations, meaning we can predict their moves from reinforcer value. K et al. add a pharmacologic twist: morphine withdrawal suddenly increases the value of the large delayed reward, a measurable swing you could plug into those same equations.
Why it matters
If you work with clients who use opioids, expect impulsive choices while the drug is on board and a possible swing toward patience during withdrawal. The pigeon data suggest the withdrawal phase, not the high, is when individuals may over-value distant rewards — a risky window if that 'big reward' is another dose. Monitor timing of drug screens or reinforcement schedules accordingly; what looks like improved self-control may be a temporary pharmacologic after-effect.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Track client delay discounting weekly during detox; note if bigger delayed reinforcers suddenly become attractive — adjust token economies before the window closes.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
When reinforcers of different magnitudes are concurrently available, choice is greater for a large reinforcer; that choice can be reduced by delaying its delivery, a phenomenon called delay discounting and represented graphically by a delay curve in which choice is plotted as a function of delay to the large reinforcer. Morphine, administered acutely, can alter responding for large, delayed reinforcers. In this study, the impact of morphine tolerance, dependence and withdrawal on choice of delayed reinforcers was examined in six pigeons responding to receive a small amount of food delivered immediately or a larger amount delivered immediately or after delays that increased within sessions. Acutely, morphine decreased responding for the large reinforcer, and the effect was greater when morphine was administered immediately, rather than 6 hr, before sessions. During 8 weeks of daily administration, morphine produced differential effects across pigeons, shifting the delay curve downward in some and upward in others. In all pigeons, tolerance developed to the response-rate-decreasing effects of morphine but not to its effects on delay discounting. When chronic morphine treatment was discontinued, rate of responding decreased in four pigeons, indicating the emergence of withdrawal; choice of the large reinforcer increased, regardless of delay, in all pigeons, an effect that persisted for weeks. These data suggest that chronic morphine administration has long-lasting effects on choice behavior, which might impact vulnerability to relapse in opioid abusers.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 2013 · doi:10.1002/jeab.25