Distressed behavior and its context.
Distressed behavior can be reinforced when it makes others back off—test this social function before you treat.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Pfadt (1991) wrote a theory paper. It asked why people with depression or chronic pain keep acting distressed.
The author said the payoff is social. When a person moans or cries, others stop being harsh. That drop in aggression rewards the distress.
No new data were shown. The paper urged clinicians to test this idea before treating any sad or pain behavior.
What they found
The main point: distressed behavior is not just a symptom. It can be an operant that is kept alive by negative reinforcement.
In plain words, crying works because it turns angry faces into gentle ones. Treat the social function, not only the mood.
How this fits with other research
Leigland (1987) made the same plea earlier: always run a functional check before you punish. Pfadt (1991) widened the lens to mood and pain.
Andrews et al. (2024) later proved the idea with kids who have Down syndrome. Their odd social acts were escape moves, just as A predicted.
Smith et al. (1997) showed what to do when the first test is muddy. They ran a mand analysis and found destructive behavior was really a request to get away.
Why it matters
Next time you see a client who looks depressed or complains of pain, pause. Ask what the behavior gets from people nearby. Run a quick functional analysis or mand check. If escape or reduced nagging shows up, teach a polite way to ask for space. You may cut problem behavior without ever treating the mood itself.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Add a 5-minute social-escape condition to your next functional analysis—praise then demand, and watch if distress spikes.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Behavior that is commonly labeled as indicating distress may have an important function in certain clinical problems. Evidence suggests that "distressed" behavior is displayed more frequently by persons who are depressed or experiencing chronic pain. Such behavior includes nonverbal facial expressions and body postures which are typically labeled as "sad," and verbal responses involving self-denigration or complaints. Such behaviors appear to form a functional response class which has a unique impact on others. The behavior appears to be more likely among persons who are receiving aversive stimulation. Recipients of distressed behavior are more likely to experience negative emotion, yet be solicitous toward the person who displays distressed behavior. Under circumstances where distressed behavior is unsuccessful in reducing aversive stimulation, the behavior may be shaped and maintained by the fact that it temporarily reduces the probability of others behaving aggressively toward the person displaying distress. Thus, the development of a pattern of high rates of distressed behavior that characterizes clinically depressed persons and persons in chronic pain may be partly a result of the unique social contingencies that surround this behavior.
The Behavior analyst, 1991 · doi:10.1007/BF03392566