ABA Fundamentals

DIFFERENTIAL RESPONSE RATES CORRELATED WITH THE PRESENCE OF "NEUTRAL" STIMULI.

KIEFFER (1965) · Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior 1965
★ The Verdict

Even 'neutral' noises can steer response speed—strip or standardize extra sounds in your sessions.

✓ Read this if BCBAs running discrete trial or natural environment teaching in noisy clinics or homes.
✗ Skip if Practitioners already working in tightly controlled, echo-free rooms with identical session tapes.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Researchers placed six rats on a fixed-interval two-minute schedule of food reinforcement. A buzzer sounded during some intervals but not others. The team wanted to see if the buzzer stayed neutral or started to control lever pressing.

No extra food followed the buzzer. The only change was the sound itself layered on top of the regular schedule.

02

What they found

Five of the six rats pressed at different speeds when the buzzer was on. One rat sped up. Four slowed down. The buzzer was not neutral; it had become a cue.

The sixth rat showed no change, proving the effect was learned, not automatic.

03

How this fits with other research

Cherek et al. (1970) later showed that louder or softer tones also guide rat pressing. KIEFFETHOMAS (1965) adds that even a tone left unpaired with food can gain control if it simply shares the session.

BOLLEHOFFMAN et al. (1964) found that monkeys release a key faster when the correct light appears. Together the papers show timing or rate shifts are sensitive signs of stimulus control across species and responses.

COLWINOGRAD (1965), published the same year, mapped how lever force changes with light color. Pairing the two studies tells us both response speed and response force can come under the sway of seemingly minor cues.

04

Why it matters

Your room is full of potential buzzers: a ticking clock, the fridge hum, your pen click. If a rat can learn to press differently because of an unattended sound, a child can learn to tan next to an unattended light. Run a quick scan of your therapy space. Remove or consistently pair any accidental cue so it helps, not hurts, your program.

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Record one session audio, listen for beeps, buzzers, or voices, and mute or make them part of the cue set.

02At a glance

Intervention
other
Design
single case other
Sample size
6
Population
not specified
Finding
positive

03Original abstract

Five out of six rats, pressing a lever for food reinforcement, showed differential rates of responding that were correlated with the presence of a buzzer, under conditions where the buzzer might have been assumed to be neutral. The effect was demonstrated when the presence versus absence of the buzzer distinguished the components of Mult FI 2 min FI 2 min, as well as when the buzzer was present throughout entire sessions of simple FI 2 min for n/2 of every n such sessions. The cause of the phenomenon was not determined.

Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1965 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1965.8-227