Cue-producing behavior in the Capuchin monkey during reversal, extinction, acquisition, and overtraining.
Extra cue-producing responses—redundant observing—predict faster discrimination reversal, echoing uncertainty-reduction accounts of reinforcement.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Thomas et al. (1968) watched capuchin monkeys during a two-choice discrimination game.
The monkeys could press a key that lit up the correct choice again—an extra “look” response.
The team tracked these cue-producing presses through acquisition, overtraining, reversal, and extinction phases.
What they found
Monkeys that blasted the cue key fastest also flipped to the new correct choice fastest.
Cue pressing spiked when the rules changed and dropped after long, predictable training.
Extra observing acts like a self-check that speeds up learning the new discrimination.
How this fits with other research
KELLEHER et al. (1963) saw bigger extinction bursts after more continuous reinforcement; R’s monkeys show the same burst but as cue-producing responses, not lever presses.
Glynn (1970) found longer training per reversal speeds later reversals in pigeons; R adds that spontaneous observing rises during those early, shaky reversals.
Corrigan et al. (1998) saw pigeons stare at the hopper when payoff timing turned uncertain; R’s capuchins stare at the stimuli when stimulus-reward links turn uncertain—same uncertainty reflex, different species.
Why it matters
When a learner starts making extra checks—peeking at stimuli, re-reading, re-scanning—treat it as fuel, not waste. Let the child flip flashcards again or re-hit the preview button; these redundant looks predict faster rule switches. You can also probe: if observing drops, the learner may have nailed the discrimination; if it surges, a reversal is coming and extra trials or prompts may help.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Count how many times your learner re-scans the array; if checks spike, insert extra reversal trials and reinforce quick shifts to the new S+.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
In a two-choice discrimination situation, a cue-producing response produced the discriminanda for 0.05 sec. The cue-producing responses beyond those normally necessary to identify the discriminanda thus provided only redundant information. Two of the four Capuchin monkeys studied showed a large increase in cue-producing responses during reversal learning and extinction, and they reversed much faster than the two whose cue-producing responses showed little increase. During acquisition of a difficult discrimination, the cue-producing responses of the first two subjects reached a high level and during overtraining gradually reduced to their initial low level. The results were related to Wyckoff's theory of observing behavior and to the notions of uncertainty, reduction, and lack of information as extensions of the concepts of reinforcement and motivation.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1968 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1968.11-425