Auditory discrimination: role of time and intensity in the precedence effect.
Tiny echo delays and small intensity cuts give near-perfect sound localization in rats.
01Research in Context
What this study did
The team worked with rats in a small lab arena. They played two clicks from different speakers. One click came first, then a second click echoed after a tiny delay.
The rats had to poke the speaker that made the first click. The scientists changed two things: how long the delay lasted and how much softer the echo was. They tested delays from 0.04 to 8 milliseconds and echo drops from 1 to 10 decibels.
What they found
Rats almost always picked the first click if the echo came 0.04–8 ms later. When the echo was more than 5 dB softer, the rats were right almost every time.
Putting both tricks together—short delay plus softer echo—pushed correct choices above 95 percent. Timing and intensity each helped, but together they gave rock-solid stimulus control.
How this fits with other research
Badia et al. (1972) showed that differential reinforcement alone can teach rats to pick the correct speaker in just one or two sessions. V et al. (1979) now show that you can get the same spot-on choices without extra rewards, as long as the echo is timed and softened just right.
Raslear (1981) later found that louder tones make rats respond more even when rewards stay equal. This backs up the 1979 idea that intensity itself can steer behavior.
Hayes et al. (1975) got peak shift with response-independent reinforcement, proving auditory control can emerge without tight reward schedules. V et al. add the rule book for echo cues that make the control almost perfect.
Why it matters
If you run auditory discrimination tasks, tweak echo delay and volume before you add extra reinforcement. A 5 dB drop and a sub-8 ms delay can lock in stimulus control with little training. Try it next time you set up speaker pairs for localization or conditional discrimination.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Lower the echo 6 dB and keep delay under 5 ms in any two-speaker task.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Rats were trained to respond on a lever adjacent to a sounding speaker (the sound source) when a single click was emitted. A second click (the artificial echo) was presented through a second speaker on the opposite side. In Condition I, the echo (equal in intensity to the source) was delayed from .015 to 32 milliseconds; greater than 75% correct responses were given for delay times between about .040 milliseconds (lower threshold) and 8 milliseconds (upper threshold). In Condition II, the echo (simultaneous with the source) was reduced in intensity relative to the source over a range from 2.5 decibels to 40 decibels; greater than 75% correct responses occurred for intensity reductions greater than 5 decibels. In Condition III, both the intensity and the delay time of the echo were manipulated in a manner analogous to that which would occur under natural conditions; greater than 95% correct responses were given for delay times from 1 to 32 milliseconds. These data indicate that both time and intensity differences are necessary for localization of primary sources, with delay time contributing more at short echo path distances, and intensity differences at long distances.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1979 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1979.32-157