Functional analysis and treatment of problem behavior exhibited by elementary school children.
A quick two-condition classroom test tells you whether to adjust work difficulty or attention, and one matched replacement skill fixes off-task behavior on the spot.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Four elementary kids kept drifting off task. Teachers needed a quick way to see why.
The authors built two short test conditions: hard math sheets versus easy work plus teacher chatter. They watched which setup sparked more off-task behavior.
After the test, they taught each child a simple replacement action that gave the same payoff the problem behavior had been getting.
What they found
Every child stayed on task longer when the teacher gave the right antecedent tweak.
Teaching one function-matched skill cut off-task behavior for all four students.
How this fits with other research
Carr et al. (1985) first showed that teaching kids to ask for attention or help can replace aggression. This 1999 study moves the same idea into regular classrooms and targets milder off-task behavior.
Slaton et al. (2024) later followed students for a full year and saw crisis procedures drop to zero. Their larger, longer outcome basically supersedes the 1999 demo by proving the effect lasts.
Weyman et al. (2022) used ultra-brief trial-based tests instead of the two-condition model. Both approaches work, but trial-based saves even more class time.
Why it matters
You can run a two-condition test in under 30 minutes, see if the trigger is task difficulty or attention, and plug in a tiny communication skill that same day. No extra staff, no clinic gear—just you, the worksheet, and a timer.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Pick one off-task student, run 5-min easy-work-plus-attention and 5-min hard-work-alone trials, then teach the function-matched request.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
A functional analysis involving antecedent events was conducted with 4 students who had been identified as having behavior problems. Off-task behavior was measured while task difficulty and level of adult attention were manipulated during analogue sessions. Results revealed two patterns: Three students displayed higher rates of off-task behavior during difficult tasks, and 1 displayed higher rates of off-task behavior during sessions with low attention. Improved behavior was observed when students were taught an alternative behavior that matched the assessment results.
Journal of applied behavior analysis, 1999 · doi:10.1901/jaba.1999.32-229