Practitioner Development

Personal agency in feminist theory: Evicting the illusive dweller.

Ruiz (1998) · The Behavior analyst 1998
★ The Verdict

Treat 'personal agency' as behavior maintained by environmental contingencies so you can analyze and change sexist reinforcement patterns.

✓ Read this if BCBAs who consult in schools or clinics where gendered expectations limit client repertoires.
✗ Skip if Practitioners looking for direct intervention data or step-by-step protocols.

01Research in Context

01

What this study did

Ruiz (1998) wrote a theory paper. It asks radical behaviorists to drop the idea of free-will 'agency.' Instead, the author says agency is just behavior shaped by environment. The goal is to make behaviorism talk with feminist theory.

Feminists worry that women get taught smaller behavioral repertoires than men. Ruiz (1998) says a true behavioral view can map those unequal contingencies without blaming the person.

02

What they found

The paper does not test people. It shows a new definition: personal agency = the person's history of reinforcement and punishment. If we use this definition, behavior analysts can study sexist environments instead of calling women 'less agentic.'

03

How this fits with other research

Malagodi (1986) and Malagodi et al. (1989) first said behavior analysts must study cultural rules. Ruiz (1998) answers that call by aiming the lens at gendered rules.

Watson-Thompson et al. (2022) and Capriotti et al. (2022) extend the same logic to racism and LGBTQ+ oppression. They use the Social-Ecological Model and cultural reciprocity to map unfair contingencies, just as Ruiz (1998) does for feminist agency.

Michael (1995) dissolves the subjective-objective split the same way Ruiz (1998) dissolves agency. Both papers turn mentalistic words into observable behavior with differing access.

04

Why it matters

When a parent or teacher says 'She needs more agency,' you can reply, 'Let's find what contingencies restrict her choices.' Map who gives reinforcement, what settings allow the behavior, and what stimuli signal boys get turns but girls do not. Then change those variables instead of waiting for the child to 'try harder.'

Free CEUs

Want CEUs on This Topic?

The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.

Join Free →
→ Action — try this Monday

Write down every place a girl's choice is blocked in your setting, then alter one contingency (e.g., equal turns at the computer).

02At a glance

Intervention
not applicable
Design
theoretical
Finding
not reported

03Original abstract

The growing impact of feminist scholarship, activism, and politics would benefit substantially from input by radical behaviorists. The feminist community, broadly defined, and radical behaviorists share interesting commonalities that suggest a potentially fruitful alliance. There are, however, points of divergence that must be addressed; most prominently, the construct of personal agency. A behavioral reconstruction of personal agency is offered to deal with the invisible contingencies leading to gender-asymmetric interpretive repertoires. The benefits of a mutually informing fusion are discussed.

The Behavior analyst, 1998 · doi:10.1007/BF03391962