By Matt Harrington, BCBA · Behaviorist Book Club · Research-backed answers for behavior analysts
The checkered flag signifies a clear victory: the second edition of Cooper, Heron, and Heward's textbook represents a major achievement for the field, providing students and professors with a comprehensive, well-crafted educational resource. The yellow flag serves as a caution: when a single textbook dominates the training of an entire profession, there are risks related to intellectual homogeneity, limited perspective, and potential gaps in coverage. The dual metaphor captures Friman's balanced assessment, celebrating the textbook's strengths while urging the field to maintain intellectual diversity.
When a single textbook shapes the training of most practitioners in a field, it becomes the de facto standard for what the field knows and how it thinks. Topics that the textbook covers well become areas of strong collective competence, while topics that are underrepresented become collective blind spots. This can limit the range of approaches practitioners consider, reduce intellectual diversity in the field, and make it harder for new perspectives and methods to gain traction. Awareness of this dynamic helps practitioners and programs take deliberate steps to broaden their educational base.
Regularly read primary research in journals such as JABA, JEAB, and BAP. Attend conferences and workshops that introduce you to perspectives and methods beyond the textbook. Engage with literature from related disciplines including psychology, education, and developmental science. Seek supervision and mentorship from practitioners with diverse training backgrounds. Join professional discussion groups that critically examine current practices. Develop a personal professional development plan that deliberately targets areas where your textbook-based education may have gaps.
While the textbook provides comprehensive coverage of core behavior analytic principles and methods, areas that may receive less attention include cultural responsiveness in practice, interdisciplinary collaboration, organizational behavior management applications, service delivery in specific settings such as schools or geriatric care, systems-level analysis, emerging technologies in behavior analysis, and the integration of behavior analysis with other therapeutic approaches. These areas are increasingly important for contemporary practice and may require additional training beyond the textbook.
The course's learning objectives specifically address school-based practice, including identifying components of effective school-based behavioral support, describing strategies for collaborating with educators, and applying behavior analytic methods in educational settings. These objectives use the textbook review as a springboard for examining how well the textbook prepares practitioners for the unique demands of school-based work, encouraging participants to identify areas where additional training may be needed for effective school-based practice.
Educators have an ethical obligation to provide comprehensive training that prepares students for the scope of practice they will encounter. This includes selecting high-quality primary resources like the textbook while supplementing them with diverse perspectives, current research, and applied case studies. Educators should model critical thinking about all resources, including assigned textbooks, and create learning experiences that develop students' ability to evaluate and synthesize information from multiple sources independently.
Evidence-based practice requires the ability to evaluate the quality and applicability of available evidence, including the evidence presented in training resources. A practitioner who uncritically accepts any resource, whether a textbook, a clinical guideline, or a published study, is not fully engaging in evidence-based practice. Critical engagement means evaluating the resource's coverage, identifying potential biases or gaps, seeking additional perspectives, and integrating multiple sources of information into clinical decision-making.
Using multiple textbooks or supplementing a primary textbook with readings from other sources can help ensure that students receive a broader perspective on the field. However, the practical challenges of multiple textbooks, including cost, coordination, and potential overlap, mean that many programs will continue to use a single primary text. The key is not whether one or multiple textbooks are used but how the program supplements the textbook with additional resources and how it teaches students to critically evaluate and extend their textbook-based knowledge.
The review tells us several things. The field has produced an exceptional educational resource that reflects significant intellectual and organizational achievement. The field is mature enough to engage in constructive self-criticism through its peer-reviewed literature. But the field also faces the risk of intellectual homogeneity when training is overly dependent on a single resource. These observations suggest a field that is accomplished but that must actively guard against complacency by continuing to diversify its training resources, welcome new perspectives, and critically evaluate its own practices.
Use the course as a prompt to evaluate how you approach training and professional development with your supervisees. Are you relying solely on textbook-based knowledge in your supervision, or are you introducing your supervisees to diverse perspectives and current research? Do your supervision discussions encourage critical thinking about established practices? Are you modeling the kind of intellectual curiosity and constructive self-criticism that Friman's review exemplifies? Incorporate discussions of primary research, diverse perspectives, and critical evaluation of standard practices into your supervision sessions.
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ on-demand CEUs including ethics, supervision, and clinical topics like this one. Plus a new live CEU every Wednesday.
Ready to go deeper? This course covers this topic with structured learning objectives and CEU credit.
Cooper, Heron, and Heward's Applied Behavior Analysis (2nd ed.): Checkered Flag for Students and Professors, Yellow Flag for the Field — CEUniverse · 1.5 BACB Ethics CEUs · $0
Take This Course →1.5 BACB Ethics CEUs · $0 · CEUniverse
Research-backed educational guide with practice recommendations
Side-by-side comparison with clinical decision framework
All behavior-analytic intervention is individualized. The information on this page is for educational purposes and does not constitute clinical advice. Treatment decisions should be informed by the best available published research, individualized assessment, and obtained with the informed consent of the client or their legal guardian. Behavior analysts are responsible for practicing within the boundaries of their competence and adhering to the BACB Ethics Code for Behavior Analysts.