Behavioral and stimulant treatment of hyperactive children: a therapy study with methylphenidate probes in a within-subject design.
Teacher praise, points, and brief time-out can lift on-task behavior in ADHD students, and adding stimulant medication pushes gains even higher.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Researchers trained teachers and parents to use praise, points, and clear rules with hyperactive students.
Each child tried low-dose, high-dose, and no methylphenidate while the behavioral plan stayed in place.
The team watched on-task behavior during regular lessons to see which mix worked best.
What they found
Behavioral training alone lifted on-task levels part-way toward the drug benefit.
High-dose medication plus the behavioral package gave the highest classroom engagement.
The combo beat either treatment by itself.
How this fits with other research
Webb et al. (1999) later showed that a quick time-out can calm disruption with or without pills.
They unpacked the 1980 “teacher package” and proved that one simple move—brief removal—does the heavy lifting.
Sulu et al. (2023) replaced adult prompts with kid-run self-monitoring and got even stronger, lasting gains.
Their update means you can now hand the clipboard to the student and still beat 1980 results.
Why it matters
You can match, and sometimes beat, medication effects with smart classroom management.
Start with teacher praise and brief time-out; add self-monitoring if progress stalls.
When medication is needed, keep the behavior plan—together they give the best shot at calm, focused learning.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Pick one student, teach the teacher to give three labeled praises each lesson, and track on-task behavior for one week.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Eight hyperactive children were treated with a behavioral intervention focusing on teacher and parent training over a period of 5 months. Three times, before therapy and after 3 weeks and 13 weeks of intervention, children received methylphenidate during 3-week probe periods. Each week in a probe they received either a placebo, .25 mg/kg, or .75 mg/kg methylphenidate. Classroom observation of on-task behavior suggested that effectiveness of the behavioral intervention was between that of the two dosages of medication before therapy. Both dosages resulted in higher levels of on-task behavior when administered after 13 weeks of behavioral intervention than when administered before therapy. Teacher rating data showed equivalent effects of therapy and the low dosage of methylphenidate alone but a stronger effect of the high dose alone; only the high dose resulted in improved behavior after 13 weeks of behavioral intervention. As a group, only when they received the high dose of methylphenidate after 13 weeks of behavioral intervention did children reach the level of appropriate behavior shown by nonhyperactive controls. However, this level was also reached by two children with the low dose and by one child without medication, and it was not reached by one child. The results suggest that the combination of psychostimulant medication and behavior therapy may be more effective in the short-term than either treatment alone for hyperactive children in school settings. In addition, parent ratings and clinic observation of parent-child interactions suggested that children had improved in the home setting, high-lighting the importance of behavioral parent training in the treatment of hyperactivity.
Journal of applied behavior analysis, 1980 · doi:10.1901/jaba.1980.13-221