Exploration of differences in types of sleep disturbance and severity of sleep problems between individuals with Cri du Chat syndrome, Down's syndrome, and Jacobsen syndrome: a case control study.
Snoring tops the sleep-problem list in Down, Cri du Chat, and Jacobsen syndromes—screen for it first.
01Research in Context
What this study did
The team compared sleep problems across three genetic syndromes: Cri du Chat, Down, and Jacobsen. They used a case-control design to see which sleep issues showed up most and how bad they were in each group.
Parents filled out sleep questionnaires. The study did not test any treatment; it simply mapped the sleep landscape for these syndromes.
What they found
Snoring was the number-one sleep complaint in all three groups. Severity of sleep problems did not differ between syndromes—snoring ruled across the board.
No syndrome had uniquely worse sleep; the main takeaway is to check for snoring first no matter which label the client carries.
How this fits with other research
Hanson et al. (2013) extends these findings to older adults with intellectual disability. They used wrist-watch actigraphy and found 72% had at least one measurable sleep problem, showing sleep trouble persists across the lifespan.
Bódizs et al. (2014) looked at Williams syndrome and saw sleep quality drop faster with age. Their method matches Griffith et al. (2012)—both profile sleep across single genetic syndromes—yet Williams adds the twist that age matters, something the 2012 paper did not test.
Masi et al. (2022) studied autistic children and linked worse sleep to lower adaptive skills and sensory issues. Together with Griffith et al. (2012), this builds a cross-syndrome picture: snoring is common, but in autism sensory factors may worsen sleep further.
Why it matters
When a client with Down, Cri du Chat, or Jacobsen syndrome shows daytime fatigue or behavior spikes, start with one quick question: ‘Do they snore?’ If yes, refer for sleep evaluation. No need to assume one syndrome sleeps worse; treat the symptom, not the label.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →Add one parent question to your intake: ‘Does your child snore loudly?’ Mark ‘yes’ for MD follow-up.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
The prevalence of sleep problems in individuals with intellectual disability (ID) seems to vary between genetic syndromes associated with ID. Different types of sleep disturbances may indicate underlying causes of sleep problems and these types of sleep disturbances may vary between different genetic syndromes. We examined and compared five types of sleep disturbance as well as severity of sleep problems in individuals with Cri du Chat syndrome (CDC), Down's syndrome (DS), Jacobsen syndrome (JS), and individuals with non-specific ID (NS). We used Simonds and Parraga's Sleep Questionnaire (1982) to assess prevalence of types of sleep disturbance and to explore differences in types of sleep disturbance and severity of sleep problems between the four diagnostic groups. In each group, mean scores for Snoring were significantly higher than those for Sleep apnea and Snoring was the most prevalent type of sleep disturbance in CDC, DS, and JS. The mean score on Complaints related to sleep was remarkably high in the JS group. There were no differences in severity of sleep problems between groups. These findings suggest that snoring is an important underlying cause of sleep problems in individuals with CDS, DS, and JS.
Research in developmental disabilities, 2012 · doi:10.1016/j.ridd.2012.04.017