Interocular generalization: a study of mirror-image reversal following monocular discrimination training in the pigeon.
Mirror-image reversal can jump between eyes after monocular training in pigeons.
01Research in Context
What this study did
Researchers trained pigeons to peck at a line with one eye covered. They then tested the birds with the other eye open.
The question: would the pigeons treat the line as if it were flipped left-to-right?
What they found
Three birds acted as if the picture was mirrored. One bird did not show the flip.
The transfer was not perfect, but it was clear enough to spot a trend.
How this fits with other research
Stretch et al. (1966) ran a near-copy study the same year. They used both eyes during training and still saw mirror peaks. Together, the papers show the flip can happen inside one eye or between eyes.
Kirkpatrick-Steger et al. (1996) later scrambled object parts instead of left-right. Pigeons still treated the new view as familiar. The pattern keeps repeating: birds treat rearranged or mirrored cues like the original.
Campos et al. (2011) pushed further, asking if pigeons can show full equivalence. They got symmetry but not transitivity. The mirror flip is real, yet full stimulus equivalence may be out of reach for pigeons.
Why it matters
The pigeon data warn us that stimulus control can jump eyes, ears, or positions in ways we do not expect. When you teach a child to follow a cue with one eye covered, check that the skill holds when the patch switches. If you see errors, try flipping the card left-to-right or rotate the seat. A quick probe saves retraining time.
Want CEUs on This Topic?
The ABA Clubhouse has 60+ free CEUs — live every Wednesday. Ethics, supervision & clinical topics.
Join Free →After patching one eye during a visual task, test the learner with the patch on the other eye and watch for left-right errors.
02At a glance
03Original abstract
Generalization gradients along a continuum of angular orientation were obtained from four pigeons, following monocular training on a discrimination between a 45 degrees oblique line (S+) and a 135 degrees oblique line (S-). All pigeons were trained on a chain DRO VI 1 schedule of reinforcement. Generalization gradients obtained with the trained and untrained eye were compared. All pigeons responded maximally to the 45 degrees line (S+) when tested with only the trained eye open. During generalization tests of interocular transfer with only the untrained eye open, three pigeons responded maximally to S- (135 degrees ), the mirror-image of the stimulus associated with reinforcement during training (45 degrees ). The other pigeon failed to show interocular transfer of the discrimination. Interocular reversal of left-right mirror-image stimuli has not been reported for any other species.
Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior, 1966 · doi:10.1901/jeab.1966.9-11